Live data from Hacker News

W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

theregister.com

31–40 of 128 posts

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#31

Hmmm, what stops Google from doing it anyway? Chrome is the de-facto standard nowadays with every other browser being under 10% market share except Safari holding out around 20%.

The article says that it’s already implemented in chrome but is disabled for the time being.

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#32
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

FireFox just follows in the steps of Chrome now. Whatever Google decides Firefox will just go along with it.

As far as consumer usage goes Firefox is effectively dead It's rare that see FF usage above 1% on any of my customers' sites and I think it's only at something like 2% on gov.uk Of course there's a debate to be had over how much FF users blocking analytics affects the numbers but the numbers tie up with the log mining I've done too

Edge Chrome already surpassed Firefox usage.

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think Firefox isn't an option? Firefox is great.

for the purposes of anti-trust law somewhere around 3% market share isn't really considered an option.

Firefox when combined with Safari are a formidable opponent to Google’s monopoly. The First Party Sets standard couldn’t be forced through because Firefox and Safari wouldn’t accept it.

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well I mean if Google shipped something in the browser that is now pretty much the only option that really helped their other business interests without getting standards imprimatur that might end up being anti-trust fodder.

Why do you think Firefox isn't an option? Firefox is great.

So is Opera

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you think Firefox isn't an option? Firefox is great.

for the purposes of anti-trust law somewhere around 3% market share isn't really considered an option.

They have a low market share now, but there's really not much of a barrier to switching. So if Chrome does still go through with implementing this, people can hop right on over to Firefox.

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#36
On one hand, W3C doesn't matter anymore. Google is the internet. On other hand there's Apple with their Safari and I have high hopes that even if Chrome implements that, Safari won't so Google will have to play by Apple's rules in the end of the day. Weird power play we are to observe.

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#38
post #37

I'm not sure why this would be such a big deal for Google.. I know they might be communicating between .co.uk .com etc.. But apart from that, why would Google benefit so much from this ?

It's not just google.com and google.co.uk, but also youtube.com, gmail.com, doubleclick.com, etc. Starting to see the bigger picture?

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#39
post #37

I'm not sure why this would be such a big deal for Google.. I know they might be communicating between .co.uk .com etc.. But apart from that, why would Google benefit so much from this ?

doubleclick.com is Google's ad platform.

Re: W3C slaps down Google's proposal to treat multiple domains as same origin

#40
post #21

Doesn't seem that different from how the web works currently, just less hacky then existing solutions. Am i missing something? Its not like the status quo is that two separate domains run by same entity can't talk to each other.

Two separate domains run by the same entity cannot share cookies, which is what this proposal is mainly about.
Post reply on HN