Live data from Hacker News

Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles

quantamagazine.org

1–10 of 65 posts

Re: Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles

#6

PBS Spacetime just released a video on this experiment. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4Ko7NW2yQo

So did Fermilab ;) https://youtu.be/ZjnK5exNhZ0

Definitely worth checking out the rest of the videos on both those channels.

While we’re at it, check out 60 Symbols’ channel for great physics discussions that hardly ever (thanks Brady!) include equations https://youtube.com/user/sixtysymbols

Re: Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles

#7

Why does it take physicists so long to find the complete foundation of the universe? I want an answer in my lifetime.

Hilbert's tomb: Wir müssen wissen Wir werden wissen

You should not be downvoted. Spare the world a little cruelty where we can.

Re: Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles

#8
post #5

Why does it take physicists so long to find the complete foundation of the universe? I want an answer in my lifetime.

So far we're struggling to reverse engineer all the perl it was hacked together with

the container that runs the simulation is extremely hard to escape from

Re: Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles

#9
post #5

Why does it take physicists so long to find the complete foundation of the universe? I want an answer in my lifetime.

So far we're struggling to reverse engineer all the perl it was hacked together with

I know you’re joking around but does the universe seem hacked together to you?

I feel like it’s incredibly elegant. All these low level rules are able to create such complex structures with beautiful order to it.

It’s so orderly, we can play things backwards billions of years. We can look back to how things were just a fraction of a second after this version of the universe began.

It’s astonishing.

Re: Muon G-2 Experiment at Fermilab Finds Hint of New Particles

#10

Why does it take physicists so long to find the complete foundation of the universe? I want an answer in my lifetime.

Physicist here:

1. One should be rather specific about what 'the complete foundation' might comprise. The depth of questions one can ask is infinite, but some questions are more important than others. The g-2 experiment is asking a specific question: "Does the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon open a door to discoveries that are inaccessible with modern colliders?"

It is tempting to regard fundamental physics as a study of "Why are we here?", but it is really a study of "How are we here?" The difference is subtle but substantial. If "Why?" is what you're seeking, you are more likely to find that answer within, rather than within the study of physics.

2. Physicists can do a lot more in these directions with greater institutional support. With great sadness, I recently departed a lab, where colleagues next-door were working on this very experiment, precisely because a collision between funding rules and administrative priorities made further progress within my specialty unsustainable. I was the third postdoc in a row to do the same; not for lack of scientific promise nor ability to attract grants.

Post reply on HN