Live data from Hacker News

Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

perens.com

11–20 of 227 posts

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#11

I'm no fan of Stallman, but I do find it worrying that some companies can unilaterally decide to sink the FSF if they don't like what it's doing. Of course, any foundation with companies on its board is at risk for that, but the fact that people who support Free Software, who ideally should shun corporate control of software, are cheering it on is disappointing, and is directly due to the kind of easy judgement peopl…

[deleted]

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#12

It seems a copout to blame his behaviour on his Autism. Plenty of people on the spectrum go about daily life without making grandiose public statements about pedophiles or eating toe jam in public - even for an Autistic person it's obvious that this will cause a negative reaction.

Indeed, being on the spectrum does not preclude being considerate, which he is most definitely not.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#13
> Thus, they are bound by the Americans with Disability Act and other applicable law to make accommodations for a handicapped employee.

Does ADA require an airline to employ a blind pilot? Besides allowing his service dog?

This essay starts with reason and ends with a slapstick statement equivalent to Walmart being required to keep employing a greeter with (movie cliche type) Tourette’s.

There is no defined end to this non judicial punishment, especially not in this case where there has been no improvement in the cause and apparently there never will be. It’s not for mr. Perens to decide differently.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#14
RMS is abusive. I'm autistic too. When I've behaved in similar ways, I've been similarly forced to account for my behavior. I resent the fact that ostensible defense of him as a person on the spectrum is so ideological. I distrust most of his defenders' sincerity when they talk about his neurodivergence, and I don't consider them allies.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#15

It seems a copout to blame his behaviour on his Autism. Plenty of people on the spectrum go about daily life without making grandiose public statements about pedophiles or eating toe jam in public - even for an Autistic person it's obvious that this will cause a negative reaction.

I mean, look at your name and have a think about what you just said.

I dont see many autistic people putting racial slurs in their names but here you are.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#16

It seems a copout to blame his behaviour on his Autism. Plenty of people on the spectrum go about daily life without making grandiose public statements about pedophiles or eating toe jam in public - even for an Autistic person it's obvious that this will cause a negative reaction.

Perhaps Larry David should produce a "toe incident" episode.

It's ridiculous that people continue to bring that up due to lack of real material.

I suspect there's more than one type of autism, in Stallman's case it seems that he has no filter at all and always speaks the truth (i.e. what he really thinks).

Give a neurotypical person a truth serum and you might be surprised. And you'll have more material that the 10 points of the Stallman inquisitors.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#17

RMS is abusive. I'm autistic too. When I've behaved in similar ways, I've been similarly forced to account for my behavior. I resent the fact that ostensible defense of him as a person on the spectrum is so ideological. I distrust most of his defenders' sincerity when they talk about his neurodivergence, and I don't consider them allies.

You clearly are not an expert on autism. The disease is a huge spectrum of different behaviors, from almost normal, to severe retardation. I've seen RMS in real life, he's borderline can't take care of himself, that's not being abusive.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#19
The FSF looks even more like a sect if you do mental gymnastics like that for your former guru.

RMS publicly defended child rape. Someone like that should not get to define what freedom means.

RMS has all the right not to get attacked about his awkward behavior, but he has to feel the consequences on his ideological thought.

Re: Bruce Perens: On Non-Judicical Punishment of Individuals

#20

> Thus, they are bound by the Americans with Disability Act and other applicable law to make accommodations for a handicapped employee. Does ADA require an airline to employ a blind pilot? Besides allowing his service dog? This essay starts with reason and ends with a slapstick statement equivalent to Walmart being required to keep employing a greeter with (movie cliche type) Tourette’s. There is no defined end to th…

A blind pilot isn’t capable of doing the job of piloting.
Post reply on HN