Live data from Hacker News

Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

axios.com

51–60 of 140 posts

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#51

A unilateral global regime is the only complete solution to prevent capital from fleeing to lower-tax locales (e.g. Cayman Islands). That said, the same incentives for smaller countries to offer lower tax rates will make them unwilling to agree to a global regime. And a global taxation regime would require a degree of international cooperation that has never been seen. Janet is laying the groundwork for a potential p…

It won't be cooperation. Either it will requiring buying off those countries or using coercion which could include anything from tariffs, fees, and penalties, or to even locking them out from access to global banking and assistance.

a global tax lets the countries with irresponsible spending to offload their costs to other countries. pure and simple. it will be packaged as something else entirely but it is no different that what happens internally in many countries between different levels of governments (states,cities, territories,etc)

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#52
Everyone here seems really in favor of this move. To me it sounds incredibly imperialistic. Why does the USA get to bully the rest of the world into their tax rates?

We clearly have a problem with multinationals leaving the country and not paying taxes. There are plenty of ways to solve that domestically without calling for some globalist tax regime.

What’s more likely: we end up with a more fair tax system, or a tax system written by the USA that looks like the USA?

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sanctions on non-compliannt countries.

This strikes me as incredibly imperialistic. Why should the USA get to decide what the tax rate is for the rest of the world?

Start with multilateral agreements, then sanction small jurisdictions that don't comply (e.g. bring the EU, US, Japan, etc on board and negotiate conditions, then impose them on Cayman Islands or Panama).

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#55

A unilateral global regime is the only complete solution to prevent capital from fleeing to lower-tax locales (e.g. Cayman Islands). That said, the same incentives for smaller countries to offer lower tax rates will make them unwilling to agree to a global regime. And a global taxation regime would require a degree of international cooperation that has never been seen. Janet is laying the groundwork for a potential p…

> capital from fleeing to lower-tax locales (e.g. Cayman Islands)

I don't think the problem is the Cayman Islands, although it's the one people think of.

Instead, take a look at the places that the big multinationals choose to put their overseas revenue through. This side of the Atlantic two high on the list would be Luxembourg and Ireland. Then look at the corporation tax rates in those jurisdictions[0].

[0] https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/sites/jrcsh/files/jrc104157.pdf

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#56
I want to believe this is a good idea, but I can't shake the feeling that these people can't be trusted in any way. Yellen herself, for all her experience in economics and monetary policy, wasn't considered suitable for her current position until she had been thoroughly bought.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/joewalsh/2021/01/01/yellen-earn...

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#57

Why don't we end all this corporate tax stupidity and remove the corporate income tax? It is a very inefficient and complicated tax to levy. >Most economists concluded long ago that it is among the least efficient and least defensible taxes. https://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/CorporateTaxation.html We can't have nice things because too many people see economics as a moral issue and not a math problem.

It is both. Corporations benefit from the existence of a well-functioning society that gives them invaluable tools to survive and thrive (they wouldn't exist without it). Why should they not contribute anything back?

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#58
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This strikes me as incredibly imperialistic. Why should the USA get to decide what the tax rate is for the rest of the world?

Start with multilateral agreements, then sanction small jurisdictions that don't comply (e.g. bring the EU, US, Japan, etc on board and negotiate conditions, then impose them on Cayman Islands or Panama).

Those multinationals are following USA tax law! Why sanction the small country when your own country enables the action?

Re: Janet Yellen to call for global minimum corporate tax rate of 21%

#59
post #44

This is the only way to stop tax evasion and a race to the bottom, with devastating consequences to people to the tune of hundreds of billions of dollars lost per year. The question is how to do this. The only way I see is unilateral action by the biggest markets: the EU and the US (plus Japan, Australia, NZ, Canada), to say "you cannot access our market if you stash your profits in a tax haven".

Yeah there’s 0 chance of that happening.

The EU can’t even agree amongst themselves.

Post reply on HN