Live data from Hacker News

Clubhouse clones are coming

philsiarri.medium.com

11–20 of 115 posts

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#12
post #5

One clubhouse is already too many. Listening to clubhouse is like turning a screen reader on your LinkedIn feed.

Hahhaha

Like a big party where only uninteresting people are allowed to speak. Like listening to your neighbors argue, except you can’t yell “shut up.”

I wrote dozens of these

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#13
post #7

Technically speaking it's difficult to see if the label 'clone' is justified given that the concept of audio only chat rooms isn't exactly new. The biggest clubhouse 'innovation' might have been to make it an invite only app and thus create a cascade of FOMO in the style of Gibson's 'antimarketing' in Zero History where someone creates the world's most sought after jeans by simply not selling it anywhere.

It isn't sticky. Sample size of one: I logged into to Clubhouse for a week, and haven't been back since.

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#14
post #7

Technically speaking it's difficult to see if the label 'clone' is justified given that the concept of audio only chat rooms isn't exactly new. The biggest clubhouse 'innovation' might have been to make it an invite only app and thus create a cascade of FOMO in the style of Gibson's 'antimarketing' in Zero History where someone creates the world's most sought after jeans by simply not selling it anywhere.

very reminiscent of the Fake Restaurant that made it to #1 on Tripadvisor (which prompted people to seek out the fake restaurant)

https://www.vice.com/en/article/434gqw/i-made-my-shed-the-to...

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#16
post #5

One clubhouse is already too many. Listening to clubhouse is like turning a screen reader on your LinkedIn feed.

On the other hand, while there are a lot of "influencer" rooms, there have been a lot of rooms where discussions I don't see going on anywhere else are happening.

I'm specifically talking about politics, things like CRT (critical race theory) and it's march through schools, business, and politics. As well as other controversial subjects.

At times they get heated but for the most part people are generally civil and the discussions can be enlightening.

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#17
Mumble's been available on Android and iOS for years. These upstarts don't all have network effects going for them. Traditionally, conference calls were something we all avoided.

Despite these things, and contrary to my expectations, these voice chats are popular. Recording quality beats a POTS line, but that's the only upside. Maybe it makes everybody feel like they're in their own podcast (their own "pod" as the kids say).

I guess this is the 21st century's version of IRC for casual, low-overhead chat. Nothing simple is ever good enough for non-enthusiasts.

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#18
post #7

Technically speaking it's difficult to see if the label 'clone' is justified given that the concept of audio only chat rooms isn't exactly new. The biggest clubhouse 'innovation' might have been to make it an invite only app and thus create a cascade of FOMO in the style of Gibson's 'antimarketing' in Zero History where someone creates the world's most sought after jeans by simply not selling it anywhere.

It isn't sticky. Sample size of one: I logged into to Clubhouse for a week, and haven't been back since.

It’s only stuck for me due to a specific real world friend who uses it. I’m pretty sure Twitter Spaces will clobber it for both of us.

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#19

Brevity was what originally made Twitter popular after the first wave of blogging. I don't think the vogue for blowhards talking at length in 'rooms' is going to last long, whether within Clubhouse or any of the other me-too cloned feature additions in other social media platforms.

Podcasts though.

Podcasts tend to be constructed rather than conversational, I tend to stop listening if it's some kind of round table format.

Re: Clubhouse clones are coming

#20
post #5

One clubhouse is already too many. Listening to clubhouse is like turning a screen reader on your LinkedIn feed.

On the other hand, while there are a lot of "influencer" rooms, there have been a lot of rooms where discussions I don't see going on anywhere else are happening. I'm specifically talking about politics, things like CRT (critical race theory) and it's march through schools, business, and politics. As well as other controversial subjects. At times they get heated but for the most part people are generally civil and th…

Yep, where the medium shines is with controversy. Live audio is simultaneously more humanizing, and less efficient, than text or pre-recorded social media. That tradeoff seems well worth it to me.

Even so, a lot of discussions still demand good/strict moderation.

And all the other growth hacking and flirting stuff is pretty cringey.

Post reply on HN