Live data from Hacker News

The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

astronomynow.com

11–20 of 40 posts

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#11

I love that this is still a topic-- along with 'is glass a fluid', this is one of the few questions I recall from childhood that turns out to still be relevant serious physics. (Re 'is glass a fluid', my condensed matter professor said something like 'if it is, it flows too slowly to observe significant movement in the lifetime of the universe'.)

Why does a mirror reverse left and right, but not up and down? and does it have something to do with us having two eyes?

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#12
post #11

I love that this is still a topic-- along with 'is glass a fluid', this is one of the few questions I recall from childhood that turns out to still be relevant serious physics. (Re 'is glass a fluid', my condensed matter professor said something like 'if it is, it flows too slowly to observe significant movement in the lifetime of the universe'.)

Why does a mirror reverse left and right, but not up and down? and does it have something to do with us having two eyes?

Physics girl explains it well: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vBpxhfBlVLU

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#14
post #11

I love that this is still a topic-- along with 'is glass a fluid', this is one of the few questions I recall from childhood that turns out to still be relevant serious physics. (Re 'is glass a fluid', my condensed matter professor said something like 'if it is, it flows too slowly to observe significant movement in the lifetime of the universe'.)

Why does a mirror reverse left and right, but not up and down? and does it have something to do with us having two eyes?

It's not reversing those, it's reversing the forward.

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#15
post #11

I love that this is still a topic-- along with 'is glass a fluid', this is one of the few questions I recall from childhood that turns out to still be relevant serious physics. (Re 'is glass a fluid', my condensed matter professor said something like 'if it is, it flows too slowly to observe significant movement in the lifetime of the universe'.)

Why does a mirror reverse left and right, but not up and down? and does it have something to do with us having two eyes?

Draw a straight line from every point on your body onto a wall and that's a mirror. To reverse up and down you would have to draw those lines in weird ways.

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#16
post #11

I love that this is still a topic-- along with 'is glass a fluid', this is one of the few questions I recall from childhood that turns out to still be relevant serious physics. (Re 'is glass a fluid', my condensed matter professor said something like 'if it is, it flows too slowly to observe significant movement in the lifetime of the universe'.)

Why does a mirror reverse left and right, but not up and down? and does it have something to do with us having two eyes?

A mirror is not reversing right and left. If you point to the right(East) your mirror image is also pointing to your right(East).

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#18
This article doesn't give either the for or the against, as we currently stand.

I'm not really sure how it's debatable, either their evidence was correct or not. Surely a respectable third person can look and tell us? The mathematics has been out for 6 weeks.

> “It is important to note that our work does not explicitly rule out Planet X/Planet 9"

I find this annoying. If it disproves their evidence, which I assume was the only known evidence for a 9th planet, then it does.

Add to this "Planet X" is tied to the original article, so if this kills all their evidence they also lose naming rights.

Re: The case for, and against, the still-unseen Planet 9

#20
post #11

I love that this is still a topic-- along with 'is glass a fluid', this is one of the few questions I recall from childhood that turns out to still be relevant serious physics. (Re 'is glass a fluid', my condensed matter professor said something like 'if it is, it flows too slowly to observe significant movement in the lifetime of the universe'.)

Why does a mirror reverse left and right, but not up and down? and does it have something to do with us having two eyes?

Look in a mirror at what's behind you, then rotate your head upwards until you're looking at the behind. Look back at the mirror.

As you can see, the mirror is reversing up and down, not left and right.

Post reply on HN