Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 49 posts

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#32
John Dewey - Art As Experience

I'm a jazz musician & artist who also studied philosophy a lot for a long time. Aged about 30 I was reading a lot of philosophy books about art, and about philosophy of music, both the classics and the latest books. Trying to understand how on earth Rachmaninov's 2nd Symphony could have the effect on me that it did. But it seemed each new book just split the subject into finer pieces, about which they knew less and less. Plus a lot of recent philosophy of music books seemed...stupid, blind, written by people unqualified to write them. Anyway, Lakoff & Johnson in Philosophy in the Flesh mention John Dewey as someone who never fell victim to the Subjectivist/Objectivist split.. So I picked up Art as Experience where it had been on my shelf for years, unappreciated. And..instantly all my problems with understanding music were solved. He talks a lot about things in everyday life—someone poking a fire, or (my favourite) a job interview!—showing how the energies, tensions, patterns are the same as those in art. Maybe sounds obvious, but the philosophy books I'd been reading got further and further from life. So, I stopped reading about philosophy of art. I'm not saying I suddenly understood everything about how art does what it does, but it was no longer a confusing, troubling problem. It just seemed natural. (Dewey doesn't have the most exciting prose style, but what he says more than compensates for that.)

Emerson - Essays

(My first book had Essays, first and second series, Representative Men, and some other stuff) It was hugely inspiring every day for many years, from when I was about 20. He writes precisely to be inspiring. He teaches you to be yourself. But also at first it was as though he'd had written about 10,000 things I'd experienced but thought were impossible to describe. If I don't read him so often now, his themes are part of me; usually it's to look up some lines I partly remember. I've probably spent more time with him than anyone.

Vonnegut - Sirens of Titan

I discovered it aged about 15. The first novel I really loved, that somehow spoke to me, that I could totally relate to. Very funny too. I read it over and over again on the school bus, a 40 minute trip, for 6 months or so. Some years I later enjoyed his Breakfast of Champions a lot too, but nothing was like Sirens. At 15 I had a telescope, was into Carl Sagan, wanted to be an astronomer, so I guess the space aspect appealed. p.s. I was later in a free jazz/rock band called The Ghosts of Saturn. Coincidentally, my brother was once in a rock band called CSI (Chrono-Synclastic Infundibulum!)

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#33

Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst by Robert Sapolsky, it is a book that explains a lot of human behavior (it's soo complicated) and as I went reading a lot of "clicks" happened in my mind of why some people do what they do.

There's a 25-part lecture series by Sapolsky on Human Behavioural Biology. Evolution, how genes work, how brains work, how emotions work etc. He's a great storyteller, very funny, apparently kind and considerate, and knows his stuff. What an amazing course. No prerequisites, I think anyone could understand and enjoy it. My very unsciency girlfriend adored it too.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL848F2368C90DDC3D

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#34
post #23

There were a few milestone books, the kind that had such an outsized impact they spring to mind almost immediately: 1. The Goal/ E. Goldratt. I read this first when I was a teenager, and kept returning to it (and some of its sequels) again and again. Adopting a systems thinking mindset. When analysing problems looking for the bottleneck, then figuring out how to elevate that constraint. 2. Topics in Algebra/ I. N. He…

The movie Adaptation., based on The Orchid Thief, is probably my all-time favourite movie. Did you see it, did you like it? Thanks, I will check out the book.

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#36

Capital by Karl Marx. Understand labor exploitation and avoid being a victim of it.

> Understand labor exploitation and avoid being a victim of it. Do you have any general tips?

I think more than tips, Marx is a highly persuasive writer. He has caused mass propaganda and death through the power of his ideas. Reading his book may open your eyes to the extent that you are exploited, which provides motivation and understanding. If I could write as well as Marx, I may lend you a tip. But the tip is read

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#37
Essay - C.S. Lewis - The weight of glory. Caused me to see all beauty in a different light.

Novel - C.S Lewis - That hideous strength. Caused me to stop thinking of conspiracy theories as people huddled in a room like the Illuminati.

Runner ups - Les Mis - helped me love the less fortunate 1984 - the importance of language.

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#38
post #37

Essay - C.S. Lewis - The weight of glory. Caused me to see all beauty in a different light. Novel - C.S Lewis - That hideous strength. Caused me to stop thinking of conspiracy theories as people huddled in a room like the Illuminati. Runner ups - Les Mis - helped me love the less fortunate 1984 - the importance of language.

Now I’m dissatisfied with what I put. There are just so many but these popped in my head first. Saw others put “the moon is a harsh mistress” ++ to that. LOTR I feel like changes me for the better with every re-reading.

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#39
Essays:

"In Praise of Idleness" - Bertrand Russell

"Planet Without Laughter" - Raymond Smullyan (there are multiple perspectives and thoughts, I was more interested in suspension of disbelief, about something known to be false but is useful)

Misc:

Some musings on socialism, capitalism, anarchy. Essays and books by Kropotkin, Engels, Marx and even Einstein are obvious recommendations

Re: Ask HN: Which book/essay changed your life?

#40
post #23

There were a few milestone books, the kind that had such an outsized impact they spring to mind almost immediately: 1. The Goal/ E. Goldratt. I read this first when I was a teenager, and kept returning to it (and some of its sequels) again and again. Adopting a systems thinking mindset. When analysing problems looking for the bottleneck, then figuring out how to elevate that constraint. 2. Topics in Algebra/ I. N. He…

The movie Adaptation. , based on The Orchid Thief , is probably my all-time favourite movie. Did you see it, did you like it? Thanks, I will check out the book.

I did see it, and seeing it was what made me notice the book afterwards. (I'm not US based, it wasn't a best seller where I was living.)

I didn't love it. But that probably says more about my taste in films than it does about the film itself...

Post reply on HN