Live data from Hacker News

RIP Google Reader

ripgooglereader.com

11–20 of 424 posts

Re: RIP Google Reader

#11
Whatever was said at the time, I’m convinced Google Reader was collateral damage from the Bay of Pigs Google Plus effort. It had social features (which I honestly never used) and anything social had to be G+.

Still, I honestly don’t understand why this is the hill people want to die on, what they feel most betrayed about. Like I haven’t seen some people this upset since Firefly was canceled.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#12

I didn't use Google Reader much, what did it do for you that made it memorable? Or perhaps, what are other Readers failing to deliver?

It actually had really good social integration with gmail. I could have conversations with close friends on items in my feed.

Hilarious, as all replacements were trying to build a social interaction.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#14

A very sad day when this was killed. It was my favorite social/intellectual experience at the time. Really never recovered from it.

The Web hasn't recovered from it, either. In retrospect, they obviously did it to pave way for AMP. Now that AMP is gone, maybe there's a small chance they could bring it back.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#15
All these years later, I still use the Google Reader frontend (with newsblur as the backend).

It turns out that Reader's UI assets were stand alone enough that you could just implement the backend API and it all would work.

I saw this originally in a project for viewing your Reader Takeout data[1], and just built on that idea to make my own personal Google Reader experience.

[1]: https://github.com/mihaip/readerisdead

Re: RIP Google Reader

#16
The real missed opportunity for Google was expanding reader's social/collaboration features into a more robust social network.It would have saved them from trying to ham fist Google+ for everyone. It could have been a home for Wave and Buzz type of tech. Instead they threw out the baby, be damn the bathwater.

That being said, I have a found NewsBlur a great replacement.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#17
post #10

I really do miss google reader from time to time ... I think I've stopped consuming RSS since it went away

Yeah, folk will say "but use xyzRSS" and just not understand how well curated Google Reader was. It was immense for content.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#18
I still miss it terribly. And it’s a constant reminder that no matter how useful or popular it is, any Google product/service/API/platform that you use or depend on could be shut down at any time.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#19

I didn't use Google Reader much, what did it do for you that made it memorable? Or perhaps, what are other Readers failing to deliver?

No competition back then.

The last interaction/version of Bloglines was really quite good, but at that point the user base has switched to Reader.

Re: RIP Google Reader

#20

A very sad day when this was killed. It was my favorite social/intellectual experience at the time. Really never recovered from it.

The Web hasn't recovered from it, either. In retrospect, they obviously did it to pave way for AMP. Now that AMP is gone, maybe there's a small chance they could bring it back.

I dunno. They easily could have integrated AMP into Reader, couldn’t they?
Post reply on HN