Live data from Hacker News

“I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

twitter.com

11–20 of 93 posts

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#11
post #8

Can anybody share some context, as to why this person is resigning?

The FSF invited Stallman back. It's become a fight internally and externally.

Twitter is on fire with passionate debates on both sides of the issue. Lots of people asked the board to resign in protest lest they be deemed supporters of RMS, and now we're seeing the board members react publicly.

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#12
post #7

When an organization, that you have a leadership position in, does something that you believe is wrong, and you have failed at preventing it and correcting it, then resignation is an entirely appropriate option. Walsh has integrity.

He didn't say that in the tweets. If that's the case, I wouldn't call it integrity to gloss over it.

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#13
post #7

When an organization, that you have a leadership position in, does something that you believe is wrong, and you have failed at preventing it and correcting it, then resignation is an entirely appropriate option. Walsh has integrity.

If thou art not a witch, then drowning is an entirely appropriate option. If you float, you have revealed yourself to be Satan/Stallman's spawn, and thou shalt be hanged.

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#14
post #8

Can anybody share some context, as to why this person is resigning?

I don't think Walsh has made an official statement of any sort about this.

But the main controversy in the FSF right now is the reinstatement of Richard Stallman.

Here's an article about the events that led to Stallman's resignation in 2019: [1]

He has also been known to, for example, hand out "Fuck Me" cards to women he deems attractive at software conferences.

[1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/09/richard-stallman...

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#15
post #9

Good riddance? I'm tired of social culture spokespeople flogging technologists over the head Nobody can make a case that RMS is a swell guy, he's awful. Still, he's without a sliver of a doubt the single most influential activist for FOSS that there's ever been. Getting rid of polarization happens with one instance of forgiveness+rehabilitation at a time. You cant cancel your way to better culture.

RMS's role in the FSF was president, and now Member of the Board of Directors. Sure this requires some technical skills, but the main factor is leadership and the ability to bring people together. If anyone believes that RMS is fit for that role, that says a lot about the state of FOSS.

What is bringing people together - RMS-style "we're here to code" or progressive "everything is politics"?

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#16
post #4

The idea of free software is a very libertarian one. You have freedom. Its the same ideology that drives concepts such as freedom of speech. It is not compatible at all with the authoritarianism that drives cancel culture. Maybe these people should get together and form their own authoritarian-left software foundation. Call it the People's Software Foundation or something. No Dang, I'm not being snarky. This is a leg…

It's ironic that you're claiming free software isn't compatible with authoritarianism while suggesting that anyone who doesn't support the Great Leader isn't welcome and should voluntarily purge themselves from the movement.

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#18
post #9

Good riddance? I'm tired of social culture spokespeople flogging technologists over the head Nobody can make a case that RMS is a swell guy, he's awful. Still, he's without a sliver of a doubt the single most influential activist for FOSS that there's ever been. Getting rid of polarization happens with one instance of forgiveness+rehabilitation at a time. You cant cancel your way to better culture.

RMS's role in the FSF was president, and now Member of the Board of Directors. Sure this requires some technical skills, but the main factor is leadership and the ability to bring people together. If anyone believes that RMS is fit for that role, that says a lot about the state of FOSS.

RMS wrote the original GPL and founded the FSF on his own. He difined a movement, and its principles. I call that leadership. More power to him.

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#19
post #9

Good riddance? I'm tired of social culture spokespeople flogging technologists over the head Nobody can make a case that RMS is a swell guy, he's awful. Still, he's without a sliver of a doubt the single most influential activist for FOSS that there's ever been. Getting rid of polarization happens with one instance of forgiveness+rehabilitation at a time. You cant cancel your way to better culture.

RMS's role in the FSF was president, and now Member of the Board of Directors. Sure this requires some technical skills, but the main factor is leadership and the ability to bring people together. If anyone believes that RMS is fit for that role, that says a lot about the state of FOSS.

So would you rather want someone who cancels or censors disenting opinions? Dogmatism has bright days ahead apparently.

Diversity was never meant to be that everyone was supposed to think the same way, as far as I recall.

Re: “I am announcing my resignation from the FSF board”

#20

Good riddance? I'm tired of social culture spokespeople flogging technologists over the head Nobody can make a case that RMS is a swell guy, he's awful. Still, he's without a sliver of a doubt the single most influential activist for FOSS that there's ever been. Getting rid of polarization happens with one instance of forgiveness+rehabilitation at a time. You cant cancel your way to better culture.

> Nobody can make a case that RMS is a swell guy, he's awful. Still, he's without a sliver of a doubt the single most influential activist for FOSS that there's ever been.

Amen to that. The sentiment around seems to ultimately be "I just don't like him because he might have made people uncomfortable, make him go away".

Post reply on HN