The visualization here is excellent, and I love watching how a link spreads through the little ecosystem of linkers of different sizes. However, I am very concerned about the headline, which suggests that HN is the most interesting part of this. I fear that posts framed this way are the first step into the pit of self-referentiality that reddit is permanently stuck in.
Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
11–20 of 23 posts
Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#12I don't see how you can possibly draw any conclusions from this. For example, if you'd reached close to the top on Reddit, would the figures progress in the same way? I very much doubt it.
Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#13http://trends.google.com/websites?q=reddit.com%2Cmetafilter....
I left digg off, because it so high that it pushes all the others down into the noise...
Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#14Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#15[deleted]
Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#16No offence, but the numbers are simply too low to read anything meaningful into them. I'm guessing you never even reached page three of Reddit, with less than 700 hits. I don't see how you can possibly draw any conclusions from this. For example, if you'd reached close to the top on Reddit, would the figures progress in the same way? I very much doubt it.
Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#17For the movie graphs, the visualizations are limited to the top twenty-five movies so it doesn't matter. But his traffic visualization shows all referrers. Those graphs would convey more information without the whitespace.
Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#18Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#19Re: Reddit vs Hacker News traffic
#20The visualization here is excellent, and I love watching how a link spreads through the little ecosystem of linkers of different sizes. However, I am very concerned about the headline, which suggests that HN is the most interesting part of this. I fear that posts framed this way are the first step into the pit of self-referentiality that reddit is permanently stuck in.