Live data from Hacker News

Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

gamerevolution.com

61–70 of 561 posts

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#61
post #37

Reddit feels very Soviet lately. Everything is heavily manipulated and it seems like users are aware of that fact but are powerless to change anything.

“Soviet” feels like a dramatic overstatement.

Have you seen the new feature where subreddit visitors get quizzed on whether or not a sub contains undesirable content?

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#62

Reddit feels very Soviet lately. Everything is heavily manipulated and it seems like users are aware of that fact but are powerless to change anything.

The subreddits I frequent seem utterly unchanged. Reddit is a big place. I understand that people refer to some ambiguous cross-section of "Reddit" as a shared space we are all aware of and can generalize about. But I don't relate to that concept at all.

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#63
post #23

Do we need scare quotes around "censorship" when reddit is telling them particular names are unmentionable in any context?

In this case, yes. For one, the original title has them. Secondly, as stated in the article, Reddit denies the allegations: > [...] admin u/landoflobsters explains that it was not the company’s intention to remove any mention of Knight’s name, but that there had been “overzealous automaton” when it came to preventing doxxing and harassment. The admin explained that an internal error had led to the suspension of a mod…

> the company had “communicated clearly” with the affected party as they resolved the situation

https://old.reddit.com/r/ukpolitics/comments/mbbm2c/welcome_...

It sounds like things are still very much opaque.

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#64

Reddit as a whole is less useful since comment sections were demoted from first class citizens to something barely usable. I think they saw imgur as a threat and wanted to better replicate that experience.

Can you expand on this? I haven't noticed any change in comment section usability and I've been on reddit for 10+ years.

Not op, pretty sure referring to the site redesign. If you force to stay on the old design, yes, you noticed nothing different. But the new design, holy shit, unless you want a Facebook's take on imgur experience, it's unusable.

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#65

Reddit feels very Soviet lately. Everything is heavily manipulated and it seems like users are aware of that fact but are powerless to change anything.

I miss humor and authenticity from old reddit the most. E.g. the classic: "I also choose this guy's dead wife." or the AMA with the vacuum repair guy.

These days just about any popular thread that I wander into, I see wide swaths of "deleted" comments. I'm sure they were deleted for many good and valid reasons.

IMHO, reddit's aggressive moderation suppresses spontaneous comments and is off putting to lurkers. The wittiest comments are likely spontaneous. And lurkers are not likely to engage in a discussion if they feel it may be off topic.

So we miss out on spontaneous humor and the random insights of brilliant people.

All of this makes reddit a sadder experience.

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#66

Reddit as a whole is less useful since comment sections were demoted from first class citizens to something barely usable. I think they saw imgur as a threat and wanted to better replicate that experience.

The new UX on the site is unusable. I don't use anything except old.reddit.com and if they ever try to get rid of that, I'll surely stop visiting the site altogether. You have to wonder how long they'll continue to maintain two different web frontends for the site, though.

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#67
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

“Soviet” feels like a dramatic overstatement.

Have you seen the new feature where subreddit visitors get quizzed on whether or not a sub contains undesirable content?

Do you know how actively free expression was repressed in Soviet Russia? Do you know about the gulags?

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#68
post #15

Do we need scare quotes around "censorship" when reddit is telling them particular names are unmentionable in any context?

Some people would argue that "censorship" would not apply to a private company owned platform. That only governments and their agents are qualified to perform act of censorship.

This is a little more nuanced than you imply. In the end, it seems they fixed the automod rule, but sub's are still actively blacking out as we speak. We'll see how far it goes, I guess!

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#69

Reddit feels very Soviet lately. Everything is heavily manipulated and it seems like users are aware of that fact but are powerless to change anything.

> lately haven't been around reddit for long then, have you

It definitely has gotten much worse in the last few years. From Spez silent-editing users posts, to reddit employing an "Anti-Evil Operations team". I've been using reddit since ~2012.

Re: Reddit’s most popular subreddits go private in protest against ‘censorship’

#70
post #23

Do we need scare quotes around "censorship" when reddit is telling them particular names are unmentionable in any context?

In this case, yes. For one, the original title has them. Secondly, as stated in the article, Reddit denies the allegations: > [...] admin u/landoflobsters explains that it was not the company’s intention to remove any mention of Knight’s name, but that there had been “overzealous automaton” when it came to preventing doxxing and harassment. The admin explained that an internal error had led to the suspension of a mod…

I moderate a reddit community with ~200k users, and if I didn't use strict filtering along with a slew of Automoderator rules I'd spend half of my day removing spam, shitposts, and submissions that break our posting rules. A few posts a day get caught by mistake, but it's a lot easier to free those posts than it is to remove the dozens of bad ones that would have made it through otherwise. I think it's at least plausible that the same type of thing happens at a site-wide level.
Post reply on HN