Live data from Hacker News

They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

texasmonthly.com

131–140 of 502 posts

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#131

There are ways that people talk about gentrification that always makes me slightly uncomfortable. As a non-white person, something always feels like gentrification is something that “good” white people like to blame “bad” white people for doing, when the real problem tends to be wider and more systemic. In this particular instance I find myself asking why it matters that the Weaver residents were originally not from…

I think people abhor change in general. I grew up in Florida, and local Floridians hated the retirees and snowbirds moving in. Former rural communities with orange groves and cow pastures were replaced with massive planned communities that altered the character and culture of the area.

The Austin-Statesman noted that people in Austin have been complaining about change in the city since at least 1884:

"A few years hence the citizen of thirty years ago will be a comparative stranger in the home of his youth with no familiar objects to greet his eye save the eternal hills on which the capitol city sits enthroned as a queen in her royal beauty and the sparkling Colorado at her feet."

In a letter (not at all dramatically) titled “Passing Away” sent to the American-Statesman 135 years ago and signed “Old Citizen,” an Austin resident expressed dismay at the news that “the buildings on the north side of Pecan Street, between Brazos Street and the alley next to the Avenue would be sold and removed.” Old Citizen lamented that “one by one the old land-marks leave us and but few of the original houses of Austin remain.”

https://www.statesman.com/news/20190204/austinites-have-been...

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#132

A variation of this rinsing out of any local culture is going on in Sacramento County California, where arguably gentrification has resulted in a 2019 autocratic edict that residents are not allowed to work on cars in their homes except fluid changes, with fines if you are found to have professional tools on the premises. https://grassrootsmotorsports.com/forum/grm/it-is-illegal-to... Since Sacramento County is appro…

Oh, this again. This law was written to give code enforcement a cudgel against unlicensed repair shops. All the auto enthusiast blogs and forums immediately lost their minds, but there hasn't been a sweep of the neighborhoods with officers asking to look inside of your garage for uncommon tools. The one complaint I could find online [1] was from a dude whose handle was "nimblemotorsports" and he said he had a car lif…

> a cudgel against unlicensed repair shops

A terrible thing in itself.

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#133
post #75

"Another Weaver resident voiced more generalized criticism, calling the event a 'display of toxic masculinity.'"

This is really depressing... It's like there's no escaping this type of mentality anywhere in the U.S. I'm currently in the process of leaving California. I won't miss it at all I'm afraid.

There is, just don't move to urban areas if you want to avoid it.

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#134

A variation of this rinsing out of any local culture is going on in Sacramento County California, where arguably gentrification has resulted in a 2019 autocratic edict that residents are not allowed to work on cars in their homes except fluid changes, with fines if you are found to have professional tools on the premises. https://grassrootsmotorsports.com/forum/grm/it-is-illegal-to... Since Sacramento County is appro…

Oh, this again. This law was written to give code enforcement a cudgel against unlicensed repair shops. All the auto enthusiast blogs and forums immediately lost their minds, but there hasn't been a sweep of the neighborhoods with officers asking to look inside of your garage for uncommon tools. The one complaint I could find online [1] was from a dude whose handle was "nimblemotorsports" and he said he had a car lif…

I dont think this is as strong defense of that law as you think. It still makes fixing car or geeking on car punisheable. It still is absurd limitation of what I would expect to be a freedom.

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#135
post #45

According to the article, this event has been happening almost weekly for years 1) Does this mean the developers did not take this into consideration and have a plan on how to deal with this or handle it? 2) Does it mean the folks buying the apartments (or renting) did not do their due diligence and find out this is a weekly event? Takeaways here (for all of us reading this story) - do you research before you move to…

This is an intentional tactic. Buy land at a discount near a nuisance, sue/threaten everyone around you into oblivion, and then enjoy your now-significantly-more-profitable house/condo/apartment building. This has repeatedly happened with the music venues, which caused them to leave that part of the city. It happened with a really nice gun range. It happened with several bars. Unfortunately the car meetup is probably…

> near a nuisance

if they were a nuisance, then getting rid of it surely isn't an issue?

The fact that there exists residential places near "nuisances" is the root cause of the problem isnt it?

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#137

Note that ownership is supplanted by rentership. I like urban density, but renting is extraction of wealth rather than a one-time transfer. I wish more of these developments were condos/ownership/co-op/what have you.

> renting is extraction of wealth rather than a one-time transfer.

why is that? Renting is merely paying for shelter. The purchase price of a property would match rentals when adjusted for the cost of the capital to purchase (aka, interest payments, lost opportunity cost of capital etc).

The only thing rentals lack is certainty - you cannot get kicked out of your owned home, but could for a rental (even with enough notice - it's still getting kicked out).

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry but this is difficult to believe. The site says that it's unlawful to do "minor vehicle repair [...] Using tools not normally found in a residence". If it was just a zoning law, why does it have to include that stipulation? I've seen plenty of people who own tools "not normally found in a residence". It's hard to guess exactly what the authors' intentions were, but it wouldn't be unreasonable for someone to…

Well, the law will be two years old soon. There's one local news article about it where the county's PIO clarified the county's intention [1]. Aside from that, alllllll of these homeowners innocently working on their cars in their own garages and yards around the county and getting hit with hundreds and hundreds of dollars in fines have resulted in... exactly zero other local news coverage that I can find. Every othe…

> Well, the law will be two years old soon. There's one local news article about it where the county's PIO clarified the county's intention [1]. Aside from that, alllllll of these homeowners innocently working on their cars in their own garages and yards around the county and getting hit with hundreds and hundreds of dollars in fines have resulted in... exactly zero other local news coverage that I can find.

Big cities with traffic problem enact this kind of laws to discourage personal car ownership. Sure, just because now it's not actively reported as enforced doesn't mean it won't be in the future, and it wouldn't be the first time where the enactment and the enforcement of a low separated in time to make the pill easier to swallow.

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd imagine one's views on gentrification are largely shaped by which side of the gentrification they're on.

As long as they personally don’t have to throw grandma down the stairs, they’re ok with it. The price of progress. Since TX doesn’t have Prop 13, they are going to be annoyed with the tents cluttering their views.

As if Prop 13 has prevented tent cities in California? California has the 3rd highest homeless rate in the country, behind only Hawaii and New York: https://losangeles.cbslocal.com/2020/12/09/california-homele...

Re: They Just Moved to Austin. Now They Want to End One of Its Traditions

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sorry but this is difficult to believe. The site says that it's unlawful to do "minor vehicle repair [...] Using tools not normally found in a residence". If it was just a zoning law, why does it have to include that stipulation? I've seen plenty of people who own tools "not normally found in a residence". It's hard to guess exactly what the authors' intentions were, but it wouldn't be unreasonable for someone to…

Well, the law will be two years old soon. There's one local news article about it where the county's PIO clarified the county's intention [1]. Aside from that, alllllll of these homeowners innocently working on their cars in their own garages and yards around the county and getting hit with hundreds and hundreds of dollars in fines have resulted in... exactly zero other local news coverage that I can find. Every othe…

The idea that giving the authorities the ability to enforce selectively on whom they like is a good thing is honestly bizarre to read. It's the classic preserve of biased prosecution.

EDIT for response since I'm rate-limited. I interpreted the following section:

> Again, I'm expressly not defending the law as it's written, but if the letter of every bad law was to be applied equally to everyone in the same instant, there would not be a single free person anywhere in the country. Like all the others, this one is being applied selectively.

as something akin to "I think the law isn't great, but if any law were applied fairly, we would all be in jail. Fortunately most laws aren't applied fairly"

But I can understand if that was a misinterpretation.

Post reply on HN