Live data from Hacker News

Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

old.reddit.com

21–30 of 415 posts

Re: Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

#22
HN is also penalising threads that discuss this. This post has 74 upvotes in 27 minutes and 11 comments at time of writing. Ordinarily it would significantly outrank most of the other posts on the front page, but it doesn't seem to be able to break past #15. Either this is because HN users are flagging it, or because something else is going on. As Reddit is a YC company it'd be really nice to hear an explanation.

This exact same thing happened with the previous threads

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26554697

and

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26556187

There are some awful transphobic comments in those threads, but they appeared _after_ the threads had been penalised.

Re: Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

#23
As much as I resent the control-weenies flagging stuff they disagree with, I don't like the title editorialising here which could be read as an attempt to shame and punish rather than discuss.

Please can we merge with the original threads and consider keeping the source titles.

Another example here with a clear and explanatory title:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDrama/comments/mb1vpb/rukp...

Re: Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

#24
My interaction with reddit is now nearly zero. I turned on ad block some time ago. I will visit /r/todayilearned in the early morning while laying in bed, and I will use subreddits to research purchases.

It is much more satisfying to remove /r/all from the reddit equation. I can't even visit my local subreddit anymore because the amount of censorship by moderators is staggering. The dark marketing, once you can see it, is everywhere. And their comment ranking algorithm is suffocating.

Re: Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

#27

Someone was banned from Reddit for linking to an article dead naming a trans woman. Did I get this right? If I did, what's the problem here, really?

I'm not sure if you are trolling, but the article wasn't "dead naming a trans woman". It was an article in a mainstream uk magazine about a uk political party where her preferred name was mentioned

Re: Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

#28
The irony is that I almost certainly would have zero idea who this person was or the existence of this controversy were it not for this crackdown.

On one hand I can empathize with people seeing someone they know have negative press about them shared on a site they run and wanting to do something. But I thought the point of professionalism was refraining from this kind of behavior and applying rules consistently even when there is a personal connection. This kind of special-case behavior in favor of people with ties to the site is likely counter productive.

Re: Reddit is banning any Aimee Challenor mention. UK public figure and Reddit admin

#30
post #11

Not dystopian sounding at all: Please do not name this individual, at all. Doing so may result in your account being banned by the admins. Please do not ask further questions about this, as doing so may result in your account being banned by the admins. Please do not discuss this incident on Reddit publicly or privately (e.g. on private subreddits and/or in private messages, chat etc.), as doing so may result in your…

And these employees are deleting subreddits (e.g. gender critical), suppress media they don't like..it's really surprising reddit has not found attention the same way twitter or facebook have. Maybe because of their political leanings.

Some media should be suppressed and some media shouldn't be. The "gender critical" subreddit for example was full of hatred for trans people like myself.

I don't believe that exercising your power to suppress something you don't like is inherently good or bad. It obviously depends on the contents of what is being suppressed.

Post reply on HN