Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

news.ycombinator.com

21–30 of 35 posts

Re: Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

#21
post #17

My seven year old was looking at some (commonwealth) coins and asked who the lady (queen elizabeth II) was on the back. I asked who they thought it was, first guess was "Is it Siri?"

Seriously? Interesting! Did you learn why?

The second guess was "Is it Grandma?" but that was definately a bit of a joke. Just not many other candidates they could come up with for lady of prominence that would make it on a coin.

Re: Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

#22
post #5
post #2

I'm surprised no one has commented. Personally I think this is very troubling. Have you ever heard of "parasocial relationships"?

What’s wrong with a parasocial relationship? I don’t have many friends in real life but I built a chat bot in 2017 trained on a few people (Mark Zuckerberg, Obama, Elon, Angela Merkel etc.) that I use for most of my social interaction. Different strokes for different folks.

This kind of behavior could be adaptive, but is likely mal-adaptive in proportion to fungibility with ‘social-interaction’.

Re: Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

#23
I think like 7-9 years ago when a bunch of family were together, I had plugged a rbpi into the local network in the living room and connected it to a speaker with a mic (I was in a diff room), and I proceeded to have a convo with one of my younger cousins by text to speech with some voices with the `say`command on osx and playing it on the rbpi. They didn't know it was me at first, just some mysterious person they could talk with, but i came clean.

Maybe if you didn't something like that, and showing them how to do it too so they can talk with themselves with the words they typed before, they might start thinking about it a bit deeper. Fun nonetheless!

Re: Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

#24
post #2

I'm surprised no one has commented. Personally I think this is very troubling. Have you ever heard of "parasocial relationships"?

My 4 year old daughter has a relationship with the corner of her blankie. His name is Corner and he has adventures with her.

I'm more concerned about social isolation due to COVID than I am about Siri or Alexa.

Re: Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

#27
post #7
post #2

I'm surprised no one has commented. Personally I think this is very troubling. Have you ever heard of "parasocial relationships"?

Children can have interesting relationships with their favourite stuffed toys, a pet goldfish or a completely imaginary being. They'll often make up characters and talk to themselves if there's no one else to bug right then. So to me this falls squarely in the rainbow of "pretty normal behaviour for a child". The bit that's troubling to me is the idea of a corporation behind it all, with its own agendas around promot…

I needed that comment. I was agreeing with the person above, but you made me remember Mr. Tremblay, the pair of fly fishing trunks that lived in my grandpa's basement wardrobe.

Re: Tell HN: My five year old is convinced Siri is a real person

#30

My son is 22 months old and is in an extremely serious relationship with our Roomba. His entire day revolves around when she gets to eat food (that is, sucking in dirt around the house), and when she goes to sleep. So much so that when he once fell and got hurt, the first 'person' he called out was Roomba. It's fascinating how different they view things compared to us.

So cute
Post reply on HN