Live data from Hacker News

Encountering Thomas Sowell

lawliberty.org

121–130 of 272 posts

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#121
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A dig at fathers in the first paragraph, and a diplomatically stated rejection of the nuclear family in the second. You need to be very generous to interpret this as anything other than an attack on the traditional family.

And across all the KPI's we know of - kids in a two parent household are more successful by every measure.

I've encountered people who say that's bad, biased, unfair, etc. - and not that we should encourage more two parent households.

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#122

Sowell is the man. Read his books.

.. and if you are wondering where to start, i'd suggest either "Basic Economics" or "Intellectuals and Society". The later being more relevant to todays culture.

Go for the bedrock with "Knowledge and Decisions"

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#123
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the language from the BLM site regarding disrupting the nuclear family. I'm very pro nuclear family. This didn't seem bad to me. -------------------------- We make our spaces family-friendly and enable parents to fully participate with their children. We dismantle the patriarchal practice that requires mothers to work “double shifts” so that they can mother in private even as they participate in public justic…

A dig at fathers in the first paragraph, and a diplomatically stated rejection of the nuclear family in the second. You need to be very generous to interpret this as anything other than an attack on the traditional family.

> A dig at fathers in the first paragraph

The writers are African-American women. Working has been a feature of most African-American women's lives for the entirety of America. It's not a dig at the fathers, who have historically also been working. The traditional African-American family has typically had two workers. (The "double-shift" is working for someone else, then coming home and doing homemaking. Commonly, the father would be working a second job during the evening hours.)

I think reading this as an attack on the traditional American family is making a lot of assumptions about which families are considered "traditional."

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#124
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Racial inequity is evidence of racist policy" if it's not, then would wildly unequal outcomes not imply some races are superior to others? the science indicates that this is not the case so how else can it be explained? --- Hmmm people didn't like this. I will add the statistic I can't get out my head: Incarceration rates in USA (adult male) per 100k White - 450 Hispanic - 831 Black - 2306 Asian - 210 I don't think…

Culture goes very deep, most of the time you don't need to bring up genes to explain differences.

[deleted]

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#126
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes and no. He doesn't burn bridges, but left of center media elites pull up the drawbridges. On topics like this, they view college activists as authoritative, objective sources of truth on race. Those activists view Sowell, and TCW, as heretics.

Recall also progressive journalist Lee Fang, who endured a cancellation campaign from colleagues at The Intercept because he Tweeted an interview with a black man who expressed concern about black-on-black crime. Many progressive activists and the media also aren't especially keen on Glenn Loury, John McWhorter, Razib Khan, or dozens of other outspoken people of color. There seems to be some strong compulsion in the…

Progressives already have the solution to the problem, therefore examining the cause can only do harm to their ideas.

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Definitely not by the average American. Twitter and San Fran/Portland are a small minority of the US.

College students too, unfortunately.

So a small minority with almost no experience raising children?

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#128
post #9

Written by Thomas Chatterton Williams [1], author of Self-Portrait in Black and White [2]: > “It’s not about color for me,” my aunt said while railing against Obama. “For example, I love Thomas Sowell.” > To that side of my extended family, I became the stereotype of a coastal liberal, writing for the New York Times and wholly out of touch with the real America. In fact, I’ve always prided and defined myself as an an…

> Why was this published in Law & Liberty, has he burned his left-of-center media bridges? No, left-of-center media is under the throes of the cultural far left, and they "de-platform" anyone who doesn't adhere to their ideology. So conservative media, along with non-traditional dissident media like Quillette, are often the only place dissident liberals like TCW can be published.

The downvotes on your post kind of prove this point.

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#129
post #34

Sowell has the great and challenging characteristic that he never quite gives you the answer that would let you justify your first reactions with, "See? He agrees with me!" His writing is too nuanced to provide an easy escape from thinking, even if people occasionally use cut-up quotes to do so.

I believe this is with great intent - ideologues of every flavor will leap at the first opportunity to claim speakers like Sowell for their faction.

The left will never admit any agreement with Sowell, even about the weather. That's what the article is about -- he's completely ignored in liberal-thinking circles, and he shouldn't be.

Re: Encountering Thomas Sowell

#130
post #98
post #2

> Many people wondered last summer why, for example, on the Black Lives Matter website the organization declared (and has since deleted) a “disruptive” stance on the nuclear family. What did that have to do with mobilizing against police violence? For a long time I was very sympathetic to BLM, I would even have considered protesting with them. It was the above that caused me to rethink my position and eventually deci…

Can anyone point me to where the millions raised by BLM after the summer riots has gone? BLM seem to cause a lot of agitation, but I am not aware of them doing anything helpful to the communities that it claims to be fighting for.

ActBlue.
Post reply on HN