Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Implementing bookmarklets in JavaScript

2ality.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

11–15 of 15 posts

Re: Implementing bookmarklets in JavaScript

#12

Post by rauschma »

dave1010uk wrote: post #9
tremendo wrote: post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I see you use the (function() {…})(); syntax in your gist, while the linked article uses (function() {…}()); I tried some simple experiment, even passing a param in the outer parens, and both seemed to work the same, and ok. Is one of these "right" and the other one "wrong"?

The former give the following message in http://jslint.com Problem at line 1 character 17: Move the invocation into the parens that contain the function. Crockford seems to prefer the latter but I don't know why.

This is purely a matter of taste. You only need the parens to tell JavaScript that it is a function expression and not a function declaration (a statement). The outer parens make an IIFE look even more block-like to me, which is why I use it. Any other prefix that tells JS that the IIFE is an expression is OK, too. For example:

    +function() { console.log("bla") }();
But: this one converts the result to a number, which you don’t want if you need the result of the IIFE. On the other hand, in places where you need that, there is usually no ambiguity with statements, anyway, and you don’t need any kind of prefix.

    var abc = function() { return "abc" }();

Re: Implementing bookmarklets in JavaScript

#14

Post by pasbesoin »

dave1010uk wrote: post #10

One of the best things about bookmarklets is that they work on mobiles too. There's a great collection of bookmarklets at https://www.squarefree.com/bookmarklets/ (Fron the same guy who tracks changes in Firefox's nightly builds: http://www.squarefree.com/burningedge/ ) You can also turn bookmarklets into GreaseMonkey scripts so they can be ran automatically on certain sites (in Firefox): http://www.squarefree.com/20…

I continue to use a number of (sometimes modified) bookmarklets from squarefree. They are also useful in skirting restrictions in environments where you are "not supposed to install stuff" (but where concerns are not so severe as to prevent execution of Javascript with which you are familiar).

It's also nice to be able to do the same things in an arbitrary set of browsers (for the most part).

Re: Implementing bookmarklets in JavaScript

#15

Post by jschuur »

thedevelopment wrote: post #7

Bookmarklets are awesome except they involve more user interaction than should be needed. I feel like almost every time I could use a bookmarklet, a plugin would do more with just as much user initiative. They also don't have a favicon (or I haven't seen one in FF4) without a user pre-visiting a destination page, so they look unpolished.

Bookmarklets are cross platform across practically any browser and work in mobile devices too. Can't say the same for plugins.

Plus it's easier for some developers to knock out a bookmarklet than a plugin, especially when you can do much of the logic server side, and potentially hook into existing code there.

Post reply on HN