Live data from Hacker News

UK to depart from GDPR

lawgazette.co.uk

21–30 of 659 posts

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#21
To 99% of internet users, GDPR has meant nothing except extra popups, blocked access to some websites, and an additional regulatory burden.

In some cases bad actors exploited GDPR for fraudulent purposes - eg. requesting a full account deletion in the event of a ban. They can then recreate the same account with the same data.

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#22

I have mixed feelings about this. On the one hand, I think GDPR is a great step towards stopping companies hoarding your data and holding you hostage to it. On the other, main GDPR change is those awful 'hand over data / pretend you're not' dialogue boxes. When I'm feeling strong, I look for the 'reject / object / blah' box, but often I don't find it in me to resist anymore. So maybe it's not awful they're reshaping…

The cookie boxes are silly and hardly represent informed consent. It should be the browsers job to do this.

I remember it used to be a thing in the netscape navigator days until everyone got sick of it.

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#23

I honestly get giggles from how unprepared they are culturally for what becoming America-like will do to them. Does anyone else? American-like but with no negotiating leverage and having burned all the bridges to the other economic unions.

The EU as a political union exists a little over a decade, if anything the UK never adapted to it.

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#24
post #6

YIPPEE. Does this mean no more of those stupid little popups every time I see a site? HOORAY. Does it mean less absurd bureaucracy and non-jobs? GREAT. As for data privacy... does anyone seriously think that Facebook was stopped from collecting data due to GDPR?

Ah this is the best bit! Because many companies cater for a global audience, us Brits will STILL have to endure the stupid little popups AND we'll have no protection or recourse from privacy invasion! Can't wait! /s

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you work in enterprise it absolutely has made a big difference.

I work in an large euroepan enterprise and our GDPR compliance is... absymal. And we're not even investing that much into becoming more compliant. My impression is that the board is in a state of denial, as doing GDPR properly would probably cost us billions.

Exactly, once Europe realises that the USA's 2018 Cloud Act makes its *impossible* for every USA registered cloud provider, every Office 365 account, every Google doc, every Gmail account, and every Dropbox account to be GDPR compliant, it will just quietly fade away.

A nice idea, but no one will care that much.

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#26
post #5

I can honestly say that I think it made little to no difference, across the board. The requirements etc have not been fulfilled by most companies, why bother.

You should've been at FAANG when GDPR hit like a ton of bricks. Compliance probably cost those companies hundreds of millions each, pretty much everything was affected.

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#27

I honestly get giggles from how unprepared they are culturally for what becoming America-like will do to them. Does anyone else? American-like but with no negotiating leverage and having burned all the bridges to the other economic unions.

The EU as a political union exists a little over a decade, if anything the UK never adapted to it.

But they benefited from the EU in a way which is no more possible.

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#28
For me the biggest flaw of GDPR that it does not distinguish between something done as a business to make money and something done non-profit, as a hobby project, etc. GDPR killed forums, etc. everything moved to Facebook groups, where people agree to whatever Facebook wants.

Who will create forum for a community if one has to deal with all the bureaucracy, "right to be forgotten", data accuracy checks, data export request, gathering consents, being responsible for bugs in some forum software if there will be data leak and risk huge fines if something is not done correctly.

Another issue is vagueness of the regulation. What exactly is data processing/controlling? If kids leave they clothes in kindergarten or school, can clothes be signed with kid first and last name (so it is easier to find lost items)? Is school a processor or controller of kids' PII in that case? Probably not, but who knows what will happen if someones signed hat will be stolen?

Re: UK to depart from GDPR

#30
post #6

YIPPEE. Does this mean no more of those stupid little popups every time I see a site? HOORAY. Does it mean less absurd bureaucracy and non-jobs? GREAT. As for data privacy... does anyone seriously think that Facebook was stopped from collecting data due to GDPR?

Facebook and google takeout only exist because of gdpr. Right to delete (not just deactivate) your account only exists due to gdpr. Right to opt out at all only exists because of gdpr, and many companies do actually stick to it. That many don't follow the spirit of the regulation is not really the fault of the regulation. Thing is its not been tested much in the courts yet, but the cases have really started last year…

Google Takeout existed for many years before GDPR was even a thing: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Data_Liberation_Front
Post reply on HN