Live data from Hacker News

We created a fake language to root out resume liars

facebook.com

461–470 of 771 posts

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#461
post #335
post #199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well yes, Greenknight gets his head lobed off, but he then puts it back on. The scary part is that in a year's time he'll get to return the favor (but doesn't, because it was a test of chivalry (and the protagonist was chivalrous)). Wikipedia has a synopsis.

Sure, but Gawain only finds that it's a test after the fact (by surviving the test due to his virtuousness). So my take away was always something along the lines of don't play games whose stakes you may not fully understand against people whose power you may not fully appreciate especially if it doesn't seem like there is a downside.

> against people whose power you may not fully appreciate especially if it doesn't seem like there is a downside.

But that's the part that makes it fun!

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#462

I've always had trouble with my worth as a developer. There are multiple reasons I won't get into, but the recruiter I used to get hired at my current employer helped me drive my salary request way North of what I was comfortable negotiating for on my own. I grappled with whether or not I deserved it, and still do at times, but I was obviously very appreciative - regardless of their reasoning. Now that I've been prom…

Seems to me you might be in a good position to start calculating an appropriate salary.

You know what your staff are paid, how productive they are, and (potentially) how their salaries figure into your organization profit-and-loss numbers.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#463

> That way, when candidates were pitched to us with "X years of MOVA experience", we knew that somebody was full of it. I'd put my money on the recruiter. I once had an excruciatingly awkward interview at a company on an industrial estate in the middle of nowhereland with no train station nearby that took me bloody ages to get to… which was actually going well until they asked me about my long experience with Exchang…

"The whole recruitment process seems broken " The IT market is pretty good compared to other fields but in the and, the market might have collapsed already. ""The Market for Lemons: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism" is a well-known[1][2] 1970 paper by economist George Akerlof which examines how the quality of goods traded in a market can degrade in the presence of information asymmetry between buyers and…

Probably some of that, plus the factors mentioned in Joel's old blog post:

In an over-simplified world of Good Developers and Bad Developers, the Good Developers generally don't get fired or quit much, and if they do, can usually get another job through references they made at their last one. If they happen to not have any references who can get them a new job and enter the general recruiting market, they usually get snapped up quickly.

Bad Developers tend to get fired or forced to quit a lot. Nobody who has experience working with them wants to hire them. They spend a lot of time on the general market applying for tons of companies that reject them. They keep doing this until they either finally learn some skills or figure out that development just isn't for them and find another line of work.

Ditto for terrible companies to work for.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#464

> That way, when candidates were pitched to us with "X years of MOVA experience", we knew that somebody was full of it. I'd put my money on the recruiter. I once had an excruciatingly awkward interview at a company on an industrial estate in the middle of nowhereland with no train station nearby that took me bloody ages to get to… which was actually going well until they asked me about my long experience with Exchang…

MOVA stands for “multiple object versionless architecture”, which is something I’d imagine any experienced full-stack developer should be able to handle- if it were real.

Did anyone else catch the hilarity of their animal choice on that fake book cover? A Lion! (Lyin') I guess a "Bull" relieving itself would have been too obvious?

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#465

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Now that is why if I ever have to send my CV to someone it will only be a PDF version. This doesn't always help either though. I have only ever sent PDFs to recruiters for this reason. Yet I have still had a recruiter completely rewrite my resume and add false information. I generally keep a resume on me when I go to an interview just in case an interviewer had not seen it. I'm glad I do that.

would digitally signing and marking as no changes possible after signing work?

Some companies want resumes submitted as text or .DOC, for easier keyword searching perhaps. Or to avoid viruses? So the recruiter may OCR the PDF, then "improve" on it.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#466
post #440
post #403

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's common practice for recruiters to replace your personal contact info with their agency's header/contact info. I don't mind that. It makes sense. I generate my resume as a PDF from HTML/CSS. It's fun to see how recruiters handle that. I think most use image manipulation to insert their header. One recruiter sent me some image assets and let me add the header/footer myself. I'm sure some recruiters go too far with…

What are these recruiters you all talk about? Are these some middlemen you contract to get you a job? Like an athlete's/actor's agent? I only had experience with recruiters who work for the organisation I'm interviewing for. None of this contact info / skills tampering makes sense in that context.

> I only had experience with recruiters who work for the organisation I'm interviewing for.

Where the hell are these recruiters at? I’ve retreated most of my information back because all I ever got was spam from the former.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#467

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The recruiter did good work here. I suspect this was a screw up in internal HR. The external recruiter has absolutely no incentive to send you for an interview you will bomb out of.

I'm not sure. Recruiters can spray and pray with candidates the way candidates can spray and pray with applications. They're not going to be great quality, but if you're paid commission on a hire and the recruitment channel can handle the load... what's to stop the recruiter?

And that's probably how I got an interview with AWS once upon a time.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#468

> That way, when candidates were pitched to us with "X years of MOVA experience", we knew that somebody was full of it. I'd put my money on the recruiter. I once had an excruciatingly awkward interview at a company on an industrial estate in the middle of nowhereland with no train station nearby that took me bloody ages to get to… which was actually going well until they asked me about my long experience with Exchang…

I just went through a little job hunt - 4 companies, 3 sets of interviews, 2 offers.

Was never once asked for a resume.

I assume everyone just looked at my LinkedIn profile, or just figured they'd learn everything they needed from talking to me.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#469
post #331

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, recruiters have accounts with companies, but in my experience the recruitment fee is a percentage of salary, and the individual recruiter compensation is on a commission model. In short, I personally have no problems in believing that the higher the salary, the higher the payment to both the recruitment company and individual recruiter. However, I think we all know that closing the deal is far more important to…

I haven't worked with a recruiter, so this is pure speculation, but it seems to me that a recruiter's greatest incentive would be to close any deal at all as quickly as possible, because they're competing against the alternative of you finding a position on your own first (or otherwise no longer requiring their services). Getting you a high salary is just gravy.

I have actually had a recruiter negotiate a salary bump on my behalf though.

Re: We created a fake language to root out resume liars

#470

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> She wasn't in a position to lose a job at the time This is an example of what universal basic income is intended to prevent.

Also strong independent labor unions.

Why on earth would anyone downvote this?
Post reply on HN