Live data from Hacker News

'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

bbc.co.uk

241–250 of 270 posts

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#241
post #166

Why is there a hovering ship but no hovering sea?

Briefly: Because the ship is above the sea. If conditions were slightly different you might also see some part of the sea hovering, or the lower part of the ship missing. In this case the "cutoff" happens to align with where the sea would end (i.e. the horizon).

It's actually a false horizon, not a superior mirage. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=er1mh90wN-k

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#243
What are the giant cities that appeared in the clouds in India and China on several occasions. I thought it was a fake the first time until I saw that there were thousands of different people who uploaded video of this. There were ,amy uploads every time it was not some crap prank. Sometimes they look like it is just an illusion of the clouds, but there ar a few times it is so obvious and thousands or maybe more people ooohhhing awwwwing and others screaming at how obvious it is. I had many different thoughts once I saw video after video and angle after angle. I have heard of project blue beam which is a pretty ominous program involving NATO countries; could these be their own versions of the technologies"? If so it truly shows the power of government to manipulate the masses to think anything in an extreme way to make over reaching changes. I mean the television has most people believing mainly lies anyway so their is obviously something nefarious planned for the future. Which CIA director was it that said once nearly everything the American public thinks and believes is false then our plan is nearly complete? Blue Beam could scare people out of the rest of their freedoms if they believe their is an alien invasion or Jesus is up their telling them to do so. hahahaha

The two party fake choice and the ral deep state which are the long term embedded scum in government all need to be cleard out. I am glad I am from Texas and we are pushing in mass for changes. Florida is doing the right thing without much push from the people.

I wish you lal the best of luck and happiness. Think for yourselves and question everything. Second best advice I ever got was that prior statement and the very best is the realization that no matter what I think I know; I know nothing for certain.

Cheers

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#244
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Something just occurred to me. Is this actually an optical illusion? My idea of an optical illusion is one where your brain perceives something that is different from reality. Indeed, when I look it up I see examples of that (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_illusion ) But in this case your brain isn't doing anything wrong, the light reaching your eyes is what's "wrong" and your brain is correctly interpret…

This is a false horizon. Your eyes are seeing the reflection of the sky on the distant water or fog, making it appear the horizon is closer than it really is. So it is an optical illusion, as your brain is what is perceiving a horizon where it is not.

What you describe here is the usual kind of mirage, the one you see when light travels over a hot surface (desert sand, road) during summer.

This particular kind of mirage ("superior mirage", as the author of the picture calls it) works the other way around: light bends away from the cold water surface. So, of I understand it correctly, the horizon appears where it really is whereas the ship appears higher up (contrary to normal mirage where the sky appears to come from the ground).

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#246
post #205

This picture will help explain the "superior mirage": https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/45/Su... Note in the OP's original link the bottom half is cut off entirely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirage?oldformat=true#Superior...

> Note in the OP's original link the bottom half is cut off entirely.

Not by any optical effect, I think -- you're seeing all that's visible of it where it actually is, too: The bit that's "cut off" is just what's hidden below the water line. (Some other post here suggested a thin line of water may actually be barely visible along the lower edge of the ship in the "mirage" photo.)

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#247

Really neat to see what deploying a containerized application to the cloud looks like! (Seriously, people. It’s been hours—has no one cracked a kubernetes joke about this yet?)

I was looking for the CSS offset joke but I like this one better

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#248
post #244
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a false horizon. Your eyes are seeing the reflection of the sky on the distant water or fog, making it appear the horizon is closer than it really is. So it is an optical illusion, as your brain is what is perceiving a horizon where it is not.

What you describe here is the usual kind of mirage, the one you see when light travels over a hot surface (desert sand, road) during summer. This particular kind of mirage ("superior mirage", as the author of the picture calls it) works the other way around: light bends away from the cold water surface. So, of I understand it correctly, the horizon appears where it really is whereas the ship appears higher up (contra…

Correction before x3n0ph3n3 has to do it again: indeed this does not appear to be either a normal nor a superior mirage.

I can only recommand to check https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=er1mh90wN-k and then https://metabunk.org/refraction/

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#249

It's strange that the air and the water below the "floating" ship is so crisp and clear. In a superior illusion, there normally is quite a bit of distortion appearing like a wall of fog or galss under the ship (or island etc). It's also strange that this was seen at a very close range when such illusions normally involve objects far away, near the horizon. Is it possible this image is a hoax, or that it was edited to…

The BBC says lots of people saw it, so I'd guess not a hoax. Sure, it could be edited, but Occam's razor suggests this guy just happened to be the one standing where it looked the clearest, so his photo was the one they selected to publish. (Also, what's to say it "was seen at a very close range" -- does the picture on the web page include meta info on what degree of zoom he used?)

Re: 'Hovering ship' photographed off Cornish coast by walker

#250
post #205

This picture will help explain the "superior mirage": https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/4/45/Su... Note in the OP's original link the bottom half is cut off entirely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirage?oldformat=true#Superior...

This _is not_ a superior mirage, it's a false horizon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=er1mh90wN-k

Thanks for clearing that up, I learned something today. That actually makes a lot of sense as well.

It’s interesting the BBC experts didn’t catch the difference but that’s the benefit of the internet I guess.

Post reply on HN