Live data from Hacker News

Why You Should Take Any Vaccine

zeynep.substack.com

91–93 of 93 posts

Re: Why You Should Take Any Vaccine

#91
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've read that up to 76% of the medical professional in some EU countries are refusing the vaccine, so I wonder why they do that if the science is so valid. Antivaxx craze and fake news network effects can only explain so much.

Not sure where this number is from. One of the main challenges of vaccine takeup in France and Germany (including health staff) is more about having a preference for the higher efficacy vaccines over the AstraZenica. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-56242617

In the case of health staff, that might actually be a good idea.

From what I've read, all of the vaccines approved for emergency use so far in the US and EU stop 100% or close to it of severe cases and hospitalizations. Vaccinated people who get COVID get a case that is no worse than a mild to moderate seasonal flu.

The high efficacy vaccines reduces your chances of getting COVID at all quite a bit more than the ones with lesser efficacy.

For someone like me, who works at home and only goes out every so often for groceries, if I get COVID there is a very good chance I'll notice symptoms before I would next go out, and so can quarantine myself and not spread it.

My main concern, then, is ensuring that if I do catch it I get at most a mild case. Any of the vaccines will do that for me, so for me it makes the most sense to take the first one offered to me.

For health staff, they won't be working at home. If they get COVID they might have plenty of chances to spread it in the couple of days or so it takes to start showing symptoms. And the people they will be spreading it to, besides other health workers, will include people who are already weakened from whatever they have come to the doctor or hospital to have treated.

So for health staff we need more than just turning their cases mild. We want to stop them from getting it in the first place. Hence, they should be getting the high efficacy vaccines.

Re: Why You Should Take Any Vaccine

#92
post #88
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Didn't realize we had anti-vaxxers in the Millenial/Gen-Z demographic but I guess idiots know no bounds...

I'm not anti vaxxer: I will be happy to take any vaccine after at least 1 year has elapsed for 10M people having received that vaccine - and I will prefer non mRNA if possible, as it is an old technology therefore very well known, and if possible the vaccine that has been injected on the most people, because it will be the one that is best known. I know that >10M people have been for 1 month, and I know that at least…

> You may call that idiocy. I call that freedom.

No, I call it selfishness. You're free to be a narcissist if you want, of course!

Re: Why You Should Take Any Vaccine

#93
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>The downvote stays. You're not a hacker news celebrity. You have no authority here. You need an ego check. I just upvoted him for no reason other than to demonstrate 1=1.

The fact that you would assign authority and credibility based upon celebrity rather than factuality is, in fact, the fundamental problem of social media. Thanks for the example in a nutshell.

No, I responded to the way you talk, as if one downvote or one upvote is a deciding factor when it clearly isn't. Yet you seem to put nonzero weight to it when 99% of votes usually stay anonymous.
Post reply on HN