Live data from Hacker News

Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

support.apple.com

231–240 of 355 posts

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imagine a service which properly integrated your phone camera (such that messaging etc worked nicely) had a desktop app and allowed network storage and backup. Have I just missed this application?

I use iPhone + Apple’s Photos app on MacOS for this, but I also include Dropbox for backing up directly from the phone and from any SD cards from other cameras. I also make a backup copy of Dropbox myself.

Is this all automatic (excluding the SD card bit)?

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#232
post #159
post #144

It is a bit sad to see something as simple as "you can now take your photos and put them where you want" become a newsworthy article. This is yet another demonstration that Digital Feudalism is alive and well, and just like its ancestor, we need to get rid of it by empowering people to be their own self

Yeah, it's the "lets you" part that ticks me off. That's the reason I have both Google Photos upload and Dropbox Upload enabled. Don't want to wake up one time to find out my photos are gone because some algo had a bad day.

You've always been "allowed" to move your photos from Apple Photos to Google Photos. The difference here is that Apple is doing it for you.

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#233

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They were required to do this by law in the EU.

And is Google required to do something similar to help users transfer their photos to a competing service?

Every service available in the EU and the UK has to do it.

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#234

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you please elaborate on that? Which particular law are they abiding?

It is covered by right to data portability included in GDPR passed in 2018. https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...

Doesn’t that say that Apple has to give you access to your photos in a format where you could then upload the photos/videos to Google? It doesn’t say that Apple has to perform the transfer for you. That’s the novelty here — Apple handling the transfer on their side without any user intervention.

Given the country list, this is being done to likely get ahead of some kind of regulation, but I don’t think this is necessarily due to this specific clause. This is above and beyond what would be minimally required.

But from other comments, it looks like this is the start of other data transfer initiatives between major tech companies. Which would be a good thing, even if it is a result of trying to avoid further regulation.

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Imagine a service which properly integrated your phone camera (such that messaging etc worked nicely) had a desktop app and allowed network storage and backup. Have I just missed this application?

I use iPhone + Apple’s Photos app on MacOS for this, but I also include Dropbox for backing up directly from the phone and from any SD cards from other cameras. I also make a backup copy of Dropbox myself.

This didn't work for me on Windows for some reason. It would transfer a few photos then the phone would go out to lunch and I'd start getting device errors, application errors, etc.

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#237
post #144

It is a bit sad to see something as simple as "you can now take your photos and put them where you want" become a newsworthy article. This is yet another demonstration that Digital Feudalism is alive and well, and just like its ancestor, we need to get rid of it by empowering people to be their own self

They were required to do this by law in the EU.

This is incorrect. The photos in Apple Photos and iCloud were already portable. Apple is now offering to do this for you which is the only notable thing about this. Nowhere in the GDPR does it say that a company has to move your data for you if requested. They just have to allow you to move it if you choose to do so and that was already the case.

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#238
post #181

Just give us a ‘download all’ button with the ability to resume in the event of a failure. RSync has been around for a long time why reinvent the wheel for every different service. Welcome to Modern tech - constantly reinventing (square) wheel

I would also like this button, but I would not be surprised if a good chunk of users have an icloud photo library so large that none of their apple devices could fit it in it's (underspeced) storage.

What an ignorant thing to say. You pretend like external hard drives don't exist.

Re: Apple now lets you transfer your iCloud Photos to Google Photos

#239
post #71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's interesting, and it's the first I've heard of the project. Unfortunately, it doesn't look like Apple has yet released the adaptors to the open source project [1]. As much as I'm not interested in having Apple copy my photos to Google, I am very interested in scripting my own offline backups without having to make space for Photos.app to store all my photos on my laptop's SSD. Hopefully the adaptors are added t…

If you are in the EU, they are by law required to give you access to your data in a way so that you can achieve this. If this is not available then you can make a complaint and maybe sue them, but that costs money.

Stop spreading this incorrect info. You already have access to this data on both Google Photos and iCloud Photos. The only notable thing is that Apple is offering to perform the transfer for you.
Post reply on HN