Live data from Hacker News

Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

arstechnica.com

11–20 of 89 posts

Re: Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

#11
post #3

So they're charging a premium (you can buy these phones in mint condition on swappa for nearly $150 less) for a refurbished 3 year old phone because it's preloaded with a ROM for enthusiasts. Who would buy this? I can't imagine any of the people who know or care enough to use /e/ are the kind of people who'd pay someone else $150 to flash a ROM for them.

I've flashed ROMs before. I don't get a kick out of it, and my hourly rate is more than $150. I'll probably buy one.

Re: Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

#12
post #3

So they're charging a premium (you can buy these phones in mint condition on swappa for nearly $150 less) for a refurbished 3 year old phone because it's preloaded with a ROM for enthusiasts. Who would buy this? I can't imagine any of the people who know or care enough to use /e/ are the kind of people who'd pay someone else $150 to flash a ROM for them.

I've flashed ROMs before. I don't get a kick out of it, and my hourly rate is more than $150. I'll probably buy one.

W... what?

Could you find someone to pay you more than $150 an hour to flash a rom?

Do you have to sit there the entire time you're setting up a phone with a new rom?

The comment you replied to is making a great point, generally people running custom roms without Google's services do so because they are enthusiasts.

An Android device without Google is going to require avoiding very common apps and using workarounds that are already going to be time consuming whether you flash the device or not.

Meanwhile people who aren't enthusiasts probably don't care about Google's hooks into Android via GPS.

-

People who apparently think... their hourly rate... is too high to flash a rom (something mostly automated anyways...) but also want to flash a rom and deal with a phone that is missing the core services that normally define an Android device on an outdated device and want to pay a 2x premium for a privilege may just be a sample size of you lol

Re: Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

#13
post #9

In Europe if we want a Google-free phone we just buy a Huawei.

I've only owned one Huawei phone, but it definitely had Google's software installed. (and after running some network analysis, I noticed it also phoned home to China)

Re: Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

#15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've flashed ROMs before. I don't get a kick out of it, and my hourly rate is more than $150. I'll probably buy one.

W... what? Could you find someone to pay you more than $150 an hour to flash a rom? Do you have to sit there the entire time you're setting up a phone with a new rom? The comment you replied to is making a great point, generally people running custom roms without Google's services do so because they are enthusiasts . An Android device without Google is going to require avoiding very common apps and using workarounds…

GP is saying that there is market for preflashed custom device even if it's 150 markup.

And I agree flashing is no fun. It takes time to find a rom that supports your device well, realize you need to root/unlock bootloader first, etc etc. Most of the time for casual flashing is spent finding the right tools and setting up.

Re: Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

#19

I live in asia how can i buy this one? Is there any way

You can follow this guide if you have one of the easy installer compatible devices: https://doc.e.foundation/easy-installer

Or on any other supported phone (see this list: https://doc.e.foundation/devices/) you can follow the install guide there. Might even work with your current phone!

Re: Google-free /e/ OS is now selling preloaded phones in the US, starting at $380

#20
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

W... what? Could you find someone to pay you more than $150 an hour to flash a rom? Do you have to sit there the entire time you're setting up a phone with a new rom? The comment you replied to is making a great point, generally people running custom roms without Google's services do so because they are enthusiasts . An Android device without Google is going to require avoiding very common apps and using workarounds…

GP is saying that there is market for preflashed custom device even if it's 150 markup. And I agree flashing is no fun. It takes time to find a rom that supports your device well, realize you need to root/unlock bootloader first, etc etc. Most of the time for casual flashing is spent finding the right tools and setting up.

Flashing is one thing, flashing without Google's services is another.

My point is if you think flashing is no fun, working around the fact Google has moved more and more functionality to Google Play Services every year is going to be even less fun.

This is a product that only enthusiasts will find fun flashing or not, so why even bother paying extra for obsolete hardware?

-

Edit because people don't like when you point out the obvious and now I'm rate-limited:

Privacy concerned smartphone "normies" have Apple. By definition "normies" are not concerned with Stallmanistic posturing about how Apple locks down their very secure devices.

If you have an ideological opposition to them that somehow doesn't apply to the large manufacturers making the phones these guys flash I'd love to know it

Post reply on HN