Live data from Hacker News

Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

arstechnica.com

51–60 of 868 posts

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#51
post #9

Ratting people out to the government is hip now... crazy times.

...and here I'm sitting, just glad that I don't have to hear "But the law enforcement officers! They're being disrespected!" any more...

(Well, to be honest I think cops do deserve respect, when they're doing their job right. Otherwise they deserve consequences.)

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#52
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Gab is a site that caters to hate groups. I guess the targets of their hatred take it personally. That seems rational to me.

Using this logic, Facebook is a site that caters to hate groups, mass murders and sexual predators. Your standard seems to be that one drop poisons the well, given that all social media is guilty of this accusation.

[deleted]

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#54
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Both market to the (mostly American) far right, with their shtick being basically "you can say anything that is not directly illegal in the US without fear of being banned or other moderation". It’s incredible that supporting free speech is considered to be only important enough to the “far right” now to be worth marketing to. Free speech used to be something all Americans supported and defended.

why do so many people confusedly assume free speech means forcing printers to print neo-nazi propaganda. Whatever happened to freedom of association? Some businesses and people don’t want to associate with neonazis and don’t want to be known as the company that helps neonazis. Why do people who espouse free speech want to take away freedom to choose who one associates with?

Hmm... so in your opinion, back in the days of the Hollywood blacklist, when Louis B. Mayer decided that he wasn't going to buy any more screenplays from communists (or anyone who even had friends who were communists), that was perfectly okay? "Freedom of association", right?

The truly bizarre thing about the "woke" movement is that they seem to have absolutely no conception that the stuff they're doing to others can just as easily be done to them.

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#55

Can someone explain the difference between Gab and Parler to someone unfamiliar with both?

Parler is basically a direct clone of twitter's basic features. They use different names but have features similar to that of Twitter's tweet/like/retweet. Gab's current iteration is a mastodon fork (although iirc they don't participate in the fediverse via activitypub). Gab is similar to Twitter like Parler but is less of a direct clone, offering other features Twitter doesn't have. Gab has been along for longer and…

[deleted]

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#56
post #46
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"friends on the left opposed to free speech" is your willful misunderstanding of the issue

These friends overtly say that free speech should be limited, in those exact terms. Not some speech, "free speech". Please let me know how you perceive me to be misunderstanding them willfully.

So free speech should include incitement of violence? Slander and libel?

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parler is basically a direct clone of twitter's basic features. They use different names but have features similar to that of Twitter's tweet/like/retweet. Gab's current iteration is a mastodon fork (although iirc they don't participate in the fediverse via activitypub). Gab is similar to Twitter like Parler but is less of a direct clone, offering other features Twitter doesn't have. Gab has been along for longer and…

> Both market to the (mostly American) far right, with their shtick being basically "you can say anything that is not directly illegal in the US without fear of being banned or other moderation". It’s incredible that supporting free speech is considered to be only important enough to the “far right” now to be worth marketing to. Free speech used to be something all Americans supported and defended.

As a South African all of this is fascinating. Especially the shift of where the "center" is.

It seemed every American not on the left is called "far right" from where I am sitting.

Half a dozen of my friends have moved to the States and a few have scolded me for my understanding saying that plenty of centrists are labeled far right.

I'm beginning to glaze over the label now. It doesn't hold any sway for me because it is used so flippantly.

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

'Free speech' means nothing at all in the private sector - but 'supporting free speech' most definitely does. If a company opts to not support free speech (which is an ideal that I believe most Americans would say should be supported) by enacting censorship rules beyond what is illegal, they shouldn't be surprised when people that believe in that ideal look on them less favorably.

By supporting free speech I support the right for us to say what we will without fear of retribution from the government. By supporting freedom of association I support that company’s can ban you for saying things they don’t agree with. Aren’t Gab and Parker right wing libertarian free market success stories? People found Twitter didn’t agree with their views so they founded a competitor.

People have felt so unheard they've taken to the streets in violence. We've seen riots all through the last year up to and including the incident on Jan 6. When people feel unheard it reliably leads to violence. That is why, when it comes to my eyes and dollars, I support platforms that support free speech. In different times I might lean towards freedom of association.

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parler is basically a direct clone of twitter's basic features. They use different names but have features similar to that of Twitter's tweet/like/retweet. Gab's current iteration is a mastodon fork (although iirc they don't participate in the fediverse via activitypub). Gab is similar to Twitter like Parler but is less of a direct clone, offering other features Twitter doesn't have. Gab has been along for longer and…

"you can say anything that is not directly illegal in the US without fear of being banned or other mode“ For a non-American, could you explain how this is far right? Sounds pretty liberal.

It is liberal, in the sense that absolute liberty is anarchy is chaos is degeneracy is suffering.

Non-degenerates know that long lasting liberty comes with responsibility, and that responsibility is moderation and correction.

The far right operates in degeneracy. They may fly the banner of freedom but they fly it alongside nazi flags so what do symbols and ideals even mean for them.

Re: Gab has been hacked and 70GB of data leaked

#60
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Slippery slopes for everyone one. And a ceo that thinks catering klan rallies makes good business would soon find it their only business. Oh wait that’s what gab and Parler is doing! And that “perhaps people new to...etc” is a nice backhanded appeal to authority and it falls flat. Edit: hacker news has rigorously enforced comment guidelines, why is that okay? Why is it not bad per what you say: > “ Because IMHO the o…

I don’t disagree with comment guidelines. Their platform, their rules. But my point is if it was my platform, I wouldn’t moderate it any more than the law requires: Imminent threats of violence, illegal pornography, libel, etc. I guess I would probably go beyond and ask people not to Dox others, and ask others not to bully or disparage one another. I find it no different from two people discussing communism in a priv…

Value isn't just a one dimensional thing where some business endeavours create less value or more value. There are different kinds of value that have different utility in different contexts.

Once you have that epiphany you can see that creating value for yourself and the people around you is a form of directing culture and vice-versa.

Post reply on HN