Live data from Hacker News

Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

github.com

251–260 of 363 posts

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#251

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But the app in the original article doesn't even work on Android. It is an ios app. The link you provide is about android, right? (Still concerning , however)

Seems you have too many HN tabs open at the same time.. But the article I have linked shows the study done on how apps read this information. Goes both ways for Android and Apple at the time, not sure if much has changed

Yeah sorry :)

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#252

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you writing that to emphasize the urgency for the government to pass legislation to reign in unregulated online casinos as they continue refining their dark patterns? (I.e., without legislation, these companies will continue finding more and more sophisticated ways to get the user to act against their own interest.) Or do you mean imply that a practical approach to reign in unregulated online casinos is to spread…

Not the poster you are replying to, but I stopped feeling empathy for people who complaint about lack of privacy, yet willingly give up their data to non-essential services that ask for it with all the proper disclosures. If you agreed to sharing all your contacts to listen to “musical tweets”, I don’t see why you’ll be complaining. You willingly made a trade off.

... willingly give up other peoples‘ data.

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#253

I don't see what the point is. "Data poisoning" gives companies a bunch of fake contacts... on top of all your real ones? Who cares? So they send some e-mails to addresses that don't exist or something? So it takes up an extra 1% of disk space in their database? If you could share an empty address book then that would actually preserve the privacy of your contacts. But this doesn't do that. I don't get it.

The vast majority of phone calls I receive are spam calls by people/robocallers which I did not give my phone number to, but apparently someone else did. I don't want people sharing my phone number with random other people

Nobody had to give them your phone number.

They just dial numbers at random. Phone numbers aren't sparsely distributed. There are entire area codes that are essentially fully utilized.

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#254

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you writing that to emphasize the urgency for the government to pass legislation to reign in unregulated online casinos as they continue refining their dark patterns? (I.e., without legislation, these companies will continue finding more and more sophisticated ways to get the user to act against their own interest.) Or do you mean imply that a practical approach to reign in unregulated online casinos is to spread…

Not the poster you are replying to, but I stopped feeling empathy for people who complaint about lack of privacy, yet willingly give up their data to non-essential services that ask for it with all the proper disclosures. If you agreed to sharing all your contacts to listen to “musical tweets”, I don’t see why you’ll be complaining. You willingly made a trade off.

Social status is a hell of a drug. Clubhouse is a place where people like Elon Musk and famous successful scientists and businesspeople hang out so all the hustler startup get-rich people want to be on board. It's exclusive, it's just for fancy iPhone users. Finally an elite place where you can only get in by invite, most cannot resist. If they miss out on the bandwagon, how can they call themselves an early adopter on the bleeding edge? What will their friends thi k of them? Almost as if they used Android or something.

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#256
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Clubhouse can bite me. I refuse to use tooling from shitbags who try to exort me into compromising others' privacy for shiny toys. I know other shops do it, as if that makes it OK.

I remember signing up for Facebook back in the day. They tried to get me to share something about my email contacts list. That just made me not use Facebook instead. Unfortunately, everyone else didn't seem to have a problem with it.

Normal people value their social standing and their relationships, bragging rights etc. higher than abstract principles. It's only loners who will resist. Popular people will be on board because they manage their brand and image instinctively. Wannabe popular too.

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#257
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean this is why they do it. You knew it was wrong, you knew they were going to take that data and mine it, and you still said sure.

In my case, I don't even remember giving them permission to use my contacts, yet I got accepted because one of my contacts sent me an invite. I might have given them permission without realizing it, but what could've also happened is that they saw my phone number in someone else's contact list, and assumed we were contacts.

You probably didn’t share, as I didn’t. I believe the contacts permission is only required if you want to share an invite, not to accept one.

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#258
post #9

Clubhouse requires contact list in order to get invites, which are required to sign up right now. I get why they are doing this, and it caused me to share my contacts with them. However, I resented it and it put me immediately in a defensive posture with the product and company. There is no possible way to trust a company with your contact list and Apple should make it how Photos works now--where you can select which…

They did something bad and yet here we are. I don't know what Clubhouse is, but I'm somewhat tempted to look it up. Marketing: successful. (I won't, in an attempt to counter that effect of growing due to negative publicity, but I find it noteworthy how well it works.)

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#259
Phone numbers are too public. The reason why they're used by messaging apps is that they are a goldmine to have. They actually make it harder to chat (ever tried using Whatsapp/Signal on a PC? Yes, you'll need to have it installed on your phone first (and have given over your contacts))

That's why I chose to set (masked) emails as the primary id on groupsapp.online and even these can't be seen publicly unless you share a "group". Others will just see XXXX@gmail.com

Re: Fake_contacts: Android app to create fake phone contacts, to do data-poisoning

#260

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean this is why they do it. You knew it was wrong, you knew they were going to take that data and mine it, and you still said sure.

Correct. I've been a member for going on a year now and I have scores of invites I don't appear to be able to send because I won't share my contacts. Not that I care enough to invite people, but it's a dark pattern to even require it. I have heard there's a way to share invites without sharing contacts, but I haven't cared enough to even do a cursory search on that.

unsync your contacts from whatever service provider you're using, make sure they're gone, go ahead and share the contacts (which are now empty) with Clubhouse, get the invites, then revert everything back?
Post reply on HN