Live data from Hacker News

Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

techcrunch.com

41–50 of 214 posts

Re: Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

#42
dsplittgerber seems to have a valid point, though one that is understood by anyone who has followed Apple for long. Still, unsure why the comment is [dead].

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2625727

To respond, Apple has never had a problem re-implementing a 3rd party app and integrating it into the system, Dashboard is a classic example of this. It's a bit hostile towards 3rd party developers, but generally good for users (at least that's the argument).

Re: Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

#43
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In my case that is a Snow Leopard disk (my MBP came with Leopard). So I have to install Snow Leopard, download and update to 10.6.7(?), and then download Lion? That's a pretty horrible user experience.

Devils advocate, is it much more of a step then downloading all the other software updates that have been released since you acquired your disc?

It is an ugly step when you have to go through 3 or 4 updates in row that require reboots.

Re: Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

#45

I wonder how much of a wrench in the works that will be for Hackintosh people.

If you install a valid registered copy of the OS on the hardware, I imagine none. For the people that obtain the OS through not so legal means, then I imagine they'll still be able to get around it as most application on the appstore are obtainable through other means.

technically none of the copies of Mac OS X running on Hackintoshes are "valid" -- Apple's Leopard/Snow Leopard boxes are technically upgrades only, not full installs, even though they work perfectly fine as full installs.

Re: Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

#46
Not sure why below comment is dead. The account seems ok and not hell banned. Was it flagged to death? If so, anyone who flagged it,why?

dsplittgerber 24 minutes ago | link [dead]

Anyone else surprised by how many hugely popular apps Apple is going to kill with new Lion/iOS? Instapaper built-into Safari now, all kinds of messanger apps killed by iMessage, some of those photo apps going down the drain as well, Reminders app is a huge one as well. All targeting really popular app categories.

Sure, some people care about thing X being done supremely well and will still pay for some apps. But the huge majority will probably be really fine with Apples version.

Re: Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

#48
post #35
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In my case that is a Snow Leopard disk (my MBP came with Leopard). So I have to install Snow Leopard, download and update to 10.6.7(?), and then download Lion? That's a pretty horrible user experience.

Pretty horrible experience for a tiny minority and a great experience for the majority. Sounds like Apple. I'm sure Macs without floppy drives were a terrible experience for people that relied on floppies.

>Pretty horrible experience for a tiny minority and a great experience for the majority. Sounds like Apple.

How will having a shipped disk as an option ruin the experience of the majority? You analogy is flawed because floppy drives take up space and cost.

Re: Mac OS X Lion: Coming In July For $29

#49

It will be interesting to see how the OS installs over itself now that it is being distributed through the app store. I wonder if they will create a new partition with the installer and reboot into it.

According to [1], Phil Schiller said "no reboots". Any idea how that is accomplished, or was it a misstatement? [1] http://www.engadget.com/2011/06/06/wwdc-2011-liveblog-steve-... , Ctrl+F for "reboots"

They probably mean no additional reboots; in many OSes first you boot the installer/upgrader, then you install, then you boot the installed OS.
Post reply on HN