Live data from Hacker News

People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

theguardian.com

11–20 of 23 posts

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#11
post #5

Ah yes, now we have studies showing people who don’t agree with the liberal left are stupid and slow. The ultimate ad hominem.

The study is actually rather neutral. All the study says is that people who are less adept at complex mental tasks are more likely to follow authoritarians.

It doesn’t say anything to the effect of people on the left or right are more intelligent than one another.

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#12
post #5

Ah yes, now we have studies showing people who don’t agree with the liberal left are stupid and slow. The ultimate ad hominem.

You don't think this also applies to extreme left too?

There is a reason for a:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horseshoe_theory

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#14
It's kind of intuitive, isn't it? There is a certain category of people who understand only simple explanations and don't like complexity, whereas most phenomena in our lives have several layers of complexity. It's natural these people are attracted to those who can provide false but simple explanations of reality.

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#16
"People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks, research suggests" ≠ "Cambridge University team say their findings could be used to spot people at risk from radicalisation"

Correlation implies causation?

I have to read the rest. But this article starts of promising.

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#17
post #5

Ah yes, now we have studies showing people who don’t agree with the liberal left are stupid and slow. The ultimate ad hominem.

The study is actually rather neutral. All the study says is that people who are less adept at complex mental tasks are more likely to follow authoritarians. It doesn’t say anything to the effect of people on the left or right are more intelligent than one another.

>All the study says is that people who are less adept at complex mental tasks are more likely to follow authoritarians.

No surprises here, is there?

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#18
What exactly is an extremist view? I wonder if the taking away of professional sports from "fanatical" viewers, or fans may also result in more people joining extremist political and religious tribes regardless of their intellect. Of course maybe sports fans are also "less able to do complex mental tasks" or is that just what the "nerds" would have us believe?

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#19
post #5

Ah yes, now we have studies showing people who don’t agree with the liberal left are stupid and slow. The ultimate ad hominem.

Given how right-shifted politics are these days, the "liberal left" is authoritarian right wing, too. So no, if this is liberals attacking conservatives, they've discovered another footgun.

Re: People with extremist views less able to do complex mental tasks

#20

It's kind of intuitive, isn't it? There is a certain category of people who understand only simple explanations and don't like complexity, whereas most phenomena in our lives have several layers of complexity. It's natural these people are attracted to those who can provide false but simple explanations of reality.

Certainly a big part of the comfort of religion for me was making a monstrous, unknowable world (which had been poorly explained to me as a kid) easier to understand. I built up a number of mental barriers to shield myself from inconvenient facts. When I went through a real bad time, it gave me simple axioms and stories that seemed to help me persevere.

Stepping away from that comfort was difficult and took time. It's also isolating. Nonetheless, I could no longer make extraordinary claims without extraordinary evidence. I'd rather know the truth of things the best I can, while I can.

Post reply on HN