Live data from Hacker News

Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

reviews.com

21–30 of 59 posts

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#21
post #2

Each decade that passes, fewer people report knowing how to drive manual carburetor chokes.

Everybody who has a piece of small power equipment with a manual choke knows how to operate any other thing with a manual choke. I suspect that the number probably peaked in the last 20yr.

Years back, in South Africa, I rented a car with a choke.

It was a cold morning, and wouldn't start.

The issue wasn't not knowing how to use a choke, but not knowing that it had a manual choke.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#22
post #15

What do people do about long hills and mountains in an automatic? I've not driven an automatic that doesn't have a manual mode in mountains. Maybe it's not that big a deal to ride the brakes the whole way down? Do modern CVTs have some sort of manual override?

Modern automatics are smart enough to downshift when coasting down a steep hill. I've driven a Duramax with the Allison up and down mountains. Absolutely amazing. You just slightly touch the brake pedal, and it downshifts and the exhaust brake enables.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#23
post #2

Each decade that passes, fewer people report knowing how to drive manual carburetor chokes.

Everybody who has a piece of small power equipment with a manual choke knows how to operate any other thing with a manual choke. I suspect that the number probably peaked in the last 20yr.

Yeah. Our generator has a choke. However, everything smaller than that is electric or an anachronism.

Arguably, the generator is an anachronism, but a comparably powered battery + solar cell would be $10,000’s, and the generator was << $1000.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#25
I hire cars a lot. I can count on one hand the autos that I’ve been satisfied with. I admit they get slightly better each year.

They’re unpredictable, too eager to shift down even in torque-y engines, annoying going up hills where they’re too eager to shift up.

The only time I really appreciate an automatic is in a big diesel car. Manuals are painful in heavy diesels, especially in start stop traffic.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#26

The article seems like a short fluff piece with the ultimate conclusion of: Why? It's easier. I've driven manual transmission vehicles for most of my adult life, my last 4 cars have been automatic. My wife isn't willing to learn how to drive one. The single thing I prefer about manual transmission vs automatic: direct throttle response If you tap the throttle, the vehicle responds to it. If you take your foot off the…

Personally, I (also) like the ability to put the vehicle easily into neutral as a part of your normal driving routine.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#27
post #2

Each decade that passes, fewer people report knowing how to drive manual carburetor chokes.

In contrast with this example (and the other nested examples), manual transmissions are still broadly available in your new 2021 vehicle straight from the manufacturer.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#28
post #2

Each decade that passes, fewer people report knowing how to drive manual carburetor chokes.

Everybody who has a piece of small power equipment with a manual choke knows how to operate any other thing with a manual choke. I suspect that the number probably peaked in the last 20yr.

Ironically, you'll still find a non-insignificant number of new motorcycles with carburetors and chokes.

Re: Each Decade That Passes, Fewer People Report Knowing How to Drive Stick Shifts

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Random question from someone who knows little about transmission, but aren't CVTs closer to giving the best of both worlds? I've driven automatic transmissions all my life, but I've really enjoyed my CVT transmission because I can go into a seven-speed manual mode (that I mostly only use for engine braking).

Reviews of many CVT equipped vehicles are pretty consistent in complaints about the transmissions. Have been looking at 5 different brands and while they offer better mileage, there are many complaints about gearing and reliability.

Car makers program CVTs to act like automatics, almost completely eliminating the benefit of a CVT. I’ve got a Subaru with a CVT and I’ve become used to it; I’ll never love it. Mine is the H6 engine paired to the heavy duty CVT. It’s a good thing it will last a long time, as it’s going to be my last Subaru (I’ve driven both the NA and turbo 4 with the CVT and would never buy one).
Post reply on HN