Live data from Hacker News

The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

matthewfraser-thismuchiknow.com

1–10 of 45 posts

Re: The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

#4
post #2

As absurd as it is, I'm pretty sick of every media outlet on earth attempting to herd me to their FB/Twitter page every time they're on air or commercial.

While I agree that it is annoying, a law is not the way to fix that. It's also very useful, as it connects the viewers with more information. I don't think anything would convince news outlets to stop since it drives up their website traffic, etc.

Re: The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

#5
Wow, this is absurd! The French official said “This would be a distortion of competition. If we allow Facebook and Twitter to be cited on air, it’s opening a Pandora’s Box —other social networks will complain to us saying, ‘why not us?’”

Nobody is saying those other networks can't be mentioned. Maybe if they would improve, they /would/ be used and get mentioned. Does my service have a right to be promoted? No? Clearly the solution is to "level the playing field" and prohibit ALL promotions!

Re: The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

#7
post #2

As absurd as it is, I'm pretty sick of every media outlet on earth attempting to herd me to their FB/Twitter page every time they're on air or commercial.

While I agree that it is annoying, a law is not the way to fix that. It's also very useful, as it connects the viewers with more information. I don't think anything would convince news outlets to stop since it drives up their website traffic, etc.

Totally agree.

I wonder how much value a news outlet derives from their follower communities and whether or not they've A/B tested the effect asking viewers to tune in on FB/Twitter hurts their ratings.

Re: The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

#8
The OP speaks about French resentment of Anglo-Saxon cultural encroachment as if it's some kind of childish French fixation ("That there is a deeply-rooted animosity in the French psyche towards Anglo-Saxon cultural domination cannot be disputed; indeed, it has been documented and analysed for decades.")

But then, remember Freedom Fries and cheese-eating Surrender Monkeys, and it seems like we all have our childish side.

Re: The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

#9
Are they banning these words from all radio and TV? Or simply not allowing government broadcasts from telling people to follow them on Twitter and Facebook? There is a huge difference between the two.

The article states "If Facebook or Twitter make the news, they can be mentioned on a strictly “information” basis. But no urging the audience to connect via Facebook or Twitter to learn more, ask questions, give their opinions, and so on."

That is quite a bit different than the impression conveyed by the headline claiming these words are completely banned.

If this regulation applies to private broadcasts too, it is wrong.

Re: The Words "Facebook" And "Twitter" Are Banned From French Airwaves

#10
post #8

The OP speaks about French resentment of Anglo-Saxon cultural encroachment as if it's some kind of childish French fixation ("That there is a deeply-rooted animosity in the French psyche towards Anglo-Saxon cultural domination cannot be disputed; indeed, it has been documented and analysed for decades.") But then, remember Freedom Fries and cheese-eating Surrender Monkeys, and it seems like we all have our childish s…

But the FCC never banned the phrase French Fries.
Post reply on HN