Live data from Hacker News

Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

franck-leroy.medium.com

51–60 of 119 posts

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#51
post #50

Articles like this while well meaning and coming from a good place are extremely naive and myopic. Do a bit of research in terms of the costs in lives and “, yes c02, of the current status quo and petro dollar complex. Do some research on how many human productive hours where lost in debasement and irresponsible monetary policy (fun fact the GFC cost around 70,000$ per American) I can go on forever and should you be…

These comments are worthless if you don't have the receipts to back them up. Be better than the rest of the internet.

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#52
post #4

And what about the CO2 impact of using traditional banking (air conditioning, heating, commuting...)

Mastercard just uses a Postgres database cluster which is significantly less computationally expensive than bitcoin. And it scales better.

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#53
post #50

Articles like this while well meaning and coming from a good place are extremely naive and myopic. Do a bit of research in terms of the costs in lives and “, yes c02, of the current status quo and petro dollar complex. Do some research on how many human productive hours where lost in debasement and irresponsible monetary policy (fun fact the GFC cost around 70,000$ per American) I can go on forever and should you be…

These comments are worthless if you don't have the receipts to back them up. Be better than the rest of the internet.

[deleted]

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#54
post #50

Articles like this while well meaning and coming from a good place are extremely naive and myopic. Do a bit of research in terms of the costs in lives and “, yes c02, of the current status quo and petro dollar complex. Do some research on how many human productive hours where lost in debasement and irresponsible monetary policy (fun fact the GFC cost around 70,000$ per American) I can go on forever and should you be…

These comments are worthless if you don't have the receipts to back them up. Be better than the rest of the internet.

https://climateandcapitalism.com/2008/03/19/global-warming-a...

https://hbr.org/2018/09/the-social-and-political-costs-of-th...

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2021-02-09/what-people...

Happy to offer much more if requested

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#55
post #22
post #4

And what about the CO2 impact of using traditional banking (air conditioning, heating, commuting...)

Is there any evidence that Bitcoin is actually displacing traditional banking? Using BTC for your savings or checking account would be an absolutely terrible idea given its volatility. No rational person would ditch traditional banking in favor of Bitcoin. So really, this is just whataboutism to deflect from the fact that, environmentally speaking, Bitcoin is one of the worst inventions of the century.

>> No rational person would ditch traditional banking in favor of Bitcoin.

There are people who have made arrangements to receive their payroll disbursements in BTC.

While there are not many of these people and they probably all still maintain some form of traditional bank account, I am curious if you would define these folks as irrational (by your definition)?

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#56

Are there any good papers on the BTC network robustness in the event of war. It is well known that major military powers have the ability to cut essentially every ocean-floor optical fiber bundle handling the backbone of the internet at a moment’s notice. If this happens, how would the bitcoin network respond without active connections to other mining nodes? E.g. would the Chinese miners automatically (algorithmicall…

This was actually one of the reasons Bitcoin Core devs were opposed to raising the block limit. Bitcoin requires very little bandwidth (around 1.5mb/10minutes).

You can actually get the Bitcoin blockchain from Satellite for free: https://blockstream.com/satellite/ However, as I understand it, it only allows receiving and not transmitting data.

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#57
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Bitcoin mining operations are generally located where electricity is cheapest. Electricity is cheapest where there is a surplus of hydro power (or other power with very low marginal cost). Where there is a surplus, use of that surplus does not drive other customers to other power sources.

By that logic, Bitcoin disincentivizes any investment in better grids and more efficient energy storage. Also, any such mining rig could have reasonably been a data center or scientific supercomputer instead.

>could have reasonably been a data center or scientific supercomputer instead.

Which would have been used for what? Supercomputer centers are having difficulty selling their cpu cycles. A data center for what? Figuring out how to better serve ads?

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#58
post #6

This is very very misleading. That bitcoin won't be used just once. After you give it to someone, they will use it too.

Which would be more compelling if Bitcoin weren’t hoarded and were actually usable as a currency.

You mean like for purchasing a tesla?

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#59
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Renewables don't exist in a vacuum: "Green" miners buying up capacity drives up the price, driving others into non-renewables as a consequence (if only temporarily). Until we are at 100% renewables, supporting a more energy-consuming product/solution/process while alternatives readily exist should not be called "green", in my opinion.

Bitcoin mining operations are generally located where electricity is cheapest. Electricity is cheapest where there is a surplus of hydro power (or other power with very low marginal cost). Where there is a surplus, use of that surplus does not drive other customers to other power sources.

Doesn't that take away from useful aluminum production?

Re: Buying a Tesla car in Bitcoins cancels 4 times the CO2 savings for its lifetime

#60
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because you don't want to "play that game", so you can just assume the financial infrastructure costs zero? Is this how you "play that game"?

It's definitely not zero, but I don't know any process in the financial industry that explicitly incentivizes wasting electricity. If business class tickets become cheaper, financial analysts will not start buying more plane tickets. Bitcoin miners on the other hand will start mining twice as fast the second the electricity price drops by half. It also doesn't seem like Bitcoin stakeholders are remotely interested in…

> I don't know any process in the financial industry that explicitly incentivizes wasting electricity

Inflation. If you don't spend your money, it loses value. This is actually part of the economic program (inflate to grow demand). What are you going to spend it on? Stuff or sevices. Stuff takes electricity to make. Services take electricity to perform.

You could also invest, but that's also just indirectly incentivising stuff and services, except in a trickle down fashion (put money into the corporation that's gonna do these things).

Bitcoin may be wasteful, but, its energy cost is explicit and not hidden, which is why it's attacked.

Post reply on HN