Live data from Hacker News

Me and ADHD

linkedin.com

451–455 of 455 posts

Re: Me and ADHD

#451

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pretty poor effort response on my part, but whenever I see a claim about a drug doing anything along the lines of "balancing neurotransmitters" I think immediately that its bs. There are probably studies that confirm some people with ADHD symtoms have less dopamine or whatever, but how each of the stims result in increases of these things is simply not specific and targetted enough to make such a claim as 'balancing'…

As someone diagnosed with ADHD and taking medications for 2 years (started at age 30), but now trying to decide if it is worth it: I believed the idea of imbalanced neurotransmitters readily, as you hear it from authoritative-sounding sources, until some reading made it clear that not only is it not true, that most serious practitioners know it is not true. I remember a talk by the author of "Mad in America" (obvious…

Medications have an effect because they are drugs and drugs work. I wouldn't read much into it beyond that. Every person will have to decide if the overall results are worth whatever cost/benefit.

The idea that the drugs "cure" or "treat" is just a social construct to justify their usage.

From first hand experience, it doesn't take much to get an ADHD diagnosis, as long as you seem credible and not drug seeking. I could ask my psychiatrist for practically any drug I wanted. It does not seem like a viable long term solution for me.

Re: Me and ADHD

#452
post #449

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Dude, I mean to copy the existing test. Also it takes much less than to get a scrip, just those shitty questionnaires. And I would if it time well spent if it helped me and others to manage their illness.

Well, you can try to copy the existing test, but you won't know how to calibrate any of the scores. It's a reaction test, based on times. The most you can copy is "see a letter, press a spacebar" functionality. They're not going to give you the source and they're not going to give you the base data. You can test people for times but you don't know the cutoffs or the norms for those times. You don't even know if high…

Nice try, big psychometrics.

Re: Me and ADHD

#453
post #445

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First, I really appreciate that you're opening up about your life. It's not easy to do, even with strangers on the web. > It's either, take that pill and turn into a robot, or... Might I suggest you think of it this way: Take that pill and realize my enlightened self or try to love myself in spite of my chemical imbalance in the brain. > can't even summarize without writing a wall of text... Although I'm not currentl…

> It's not easy to do, even with strangers on the web Sometimes I get a good feeling, and this comment section gave me one :) Seems like the place to write about ADHD. > Take that pill and realize my enlightened self or try to love myself in spite of my chemical imbalance in the brain That's actually a good quote, thanks for coming up with it :) > JOURNAL your personal thoughts, it's really helpful to realizing what…

Consider trying elvanse / vyvanse.

While concerta did help in some sense, I had the same side effects as you. In my experience, Elvanse feels more like it "cures" my ADHD while retaining my personality and creativity. Oh, and (almost) no side effects!

Re: Me and ADHD

#454
post #445

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It's not easy to do, even with strangers on the web Sometimes I get a good feeling, and this comment section gave me one :) Seems like the place to write about ADHD. > Take that pill and realize my enlightened self or try to love myself in spite of my chemical imbalance in the brain That's actually a good quote, thanks for coming up with it :) > JOURNAL your personal thoughts, it's really helpful to realizing what…

Consider trying elvanse / vyvanse. While concerta did help in some sense, I had the same side effects as you. In my experience, Elvanse feels more like it "cures" my ADHD while retaining my personality and creativity. Oh, and (almost) no side effects!

I've wanted to try that, yeah. Heard a lot of good stuff about it :) I'll have to check that out with my doc, thanks for the recommendation!

Re: Me and ADHD

#455

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The difference between people is so subtle and so profound. For me, dextroamphetamine brings a still and composed calmness upon the world. Not euphora, just a calmness.

How about heart rate and blood pressure? I get the same reaction as you - I'm calm, still, patient. Much more "present" with my wife and far less likely to argue. If I need to plan, or organize something, the initial feeling of "oof" is no longer there. I just do the task. I have however noticed that my heart rate (normally in the low 50s) hovers in the low 60s. I assume (but have not checked) that my blood pressure…

Blood pressure is normal; Slightly lower than before. Heart rate is up a bit - from about 60 to about 67 resting heart rate - BUT the two years I have been prescribed lisdexamfetamine have brought exceptionally and unusually stressful personal events and I've unfortunately not been able to exercise as much as before. The medicine has certainly helped us cope, however!
Post reply on HN