I agree with this (other than maybe hating to see Homebrew “win”). And I’ll add:
And although I’m not arguing Homebrew is above reproach or critique, some of the criticism here seems both a little unfounded and a little bit ignorant (either willfully or because people just don’t know/remember) about the state of package managers BEFORE Homebrew. Like you, I used MacPorts/Darwinports and Fink for years before Homebrew was a thing and have immense respect for all three of those projects (even though DP merged with MP over a decade ago, my mind still sees them as separate things) and the massive role they played in my own life and development as a developer, but Homebrew didn’t just pop-up and supplant the existing options and through nefarious means.
At the time that it came to existence, despite the very good existing options, those communities and their progress had stagnated — at least from the perspective of the end user. There was a wealth of older packages, but newer stuff wasn’t there. And the death of PPC with Snow Leopard hit subsets of that community hard. It wasn’t just that Homebrew was easier to use and install (though it was, a bit), it was that it had more modern and more frequently updated packages.
I distinctly remember when Homebrew first arrived, my initial reaction was, “why do I need this, I already have MacPorts?” But then I used it and found that people were bottling up newer stuff at a much more rapid pace and the tools embraced by that community were modern and frankly, to an outsider, much more accessible. As you said, choosing GitHub over MacForge or whatever was a great choice too.
MP has had a renaissance of sorts over the years which has been amazing to see. I think having options is awesome. But Homebrew was very much filling a void for some beloved projects that had fallen behind. It’s hard to win that momentum back, once the community (including a whole generation of new users) goes to the new thing.
We’ve seen that with Mac text editors too. TextMate, to me, is still one of the best editors I’ve ever used and I would argue is one of the most influential software applications of the aughts. But as it faced all of its challenges to move to 2.0 (the feature creep, the technical challenges, the scope changes), it created a window for Sublime to come in and take the the extension community (which was really pioneered in the way that it worked by TextMate), and thus the userbase with it. And when Sublime faced similar challenges in its own troubled releases (for some of the same but also different reasons that TextMate had), we again saw momentum shift to VS Code.