Live data from Hacker News

Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

hamakor.org.il

1–10 of 12 posts

Re: Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

#2
According to Google Translate, the Hebrew reads:

Attached is Stallman's announcement about the lecture in Israel. I enclose my response (I put it after the announcement of Stallman) only because I see Stallman's decision is contrary to the logic of freedom of expression.

Eddie

-

Am I the only one who thought, "Holy shit, that translates incredibly well to English."?

Re: Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

#3

According to Google Translate, the Hebrew reads: Attached is Stallman's announcement about the lecture in Israel. I enclose my response (I put it after the announcement of Stallman) only because I see Stallman's decision is contrary to the logic of freedom of expression. Eddie - Am I the only one who thought, "Holy shit, that translates incredibly well to English."?

I shoulda translate the Hebrew part... (yet I think Google translate did a better job than I would have...) Thanks for the translate.

Re: Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

#4
Stallman lays out the choice he had to make clearly, and he made a valid choice. That choice does not constitute /his/ boycotting Israeli Universities at all, only declining to cause distress or offence to the people who are paying for his trip. Based on his own account, he would be happy to speak at Israeli Universities, so the title of this post is wilfully misleading.

Re: Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

#7
post #6

Interesting. RMS is aggressively against software coercion but ambivalent to political coercion.

not so. he is simply respectful of his hosts, who are paying for his trip. there is no evidence of partiality on his part in the facts presented, only on the part of his hosts.

Re: Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

#8
post #7
post #6

Interesting. RMS is aggressively against software coercion but ambivalent to political coercion.

not so. he is simply respectful of his hosts, who are paying for his trip. there is no evidence of partiality on his part in the facts presented, only on the part of his hosts.

Respectful of his hosts? Don't think so. They kind of twisted his arm. It would have not happen the other way around by the way (if the Israelis were paying for his trip).

Re: Richard Stallman cancels talks at Israeli universities

#10
post #8
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

not so. he is simply respectful of his hosts, who are paying for his trip. there is no evidence of partiality on his part in the facts presented, only on the part of his hosts.

Respectful of his hosts? Don't think so. They kind of twisted his arm. It would have not happen the other way around by the way (if the Israelis were paying for his trip).

how do you know? have you asked him?
Post reply on HN