Live data from Hacker News

Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

play.google.com

21–30 of 547 posts

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#21
post #8

I'm surprised the app stores (well, at least the play store) don't have hysteresis built in to prevent mobbing the ratings, just in general.

Why would they? They just need spam protection. If legitimate, independent users vote them down in thousands then why would an app need a protection?

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#22
There should be zero stars available for scamsters. Seriously this should be an option. Why should anyone give one star to a scamming firm Robbing Hood which has colluded with their backer Citadel. They have derogatory term for Retail Investors - Dumb Money. Now the 'Dumb Money' has figured out the the hedge funds'rigged game.

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#25

Still 4.8 on the App Store though

I believe App Store updates a day later, so we're likely not seeing the results of any mass rating bombs.

Not exactly a day later but the ratings tend to come with 6 to 12 hours delay. Sometimes more.

Also, there's this strange thing that some of the ratings disappear and come back later or not.

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#26

I wonder what percentage of Robinhood users hold GME - if it's more than 25% I'd say they're finished. If we assume 25% of users hold GME and 80% of GME holders will not return after this fiasco that's extremely significant IMO. Not to say that they'll cease to exist, but I doubt they'll remain the "#1 trading platform."

According to Motherboard it's more than half.

https://twitter.com/motherboard/status/1354798244455395328

EDIT: This is untrue, please refer to jaywalk's reply.

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#27
post #7

Can someone who knows more about such things than I explain to me why their weird response to the situation (halting buying, but still permitting selling) was deemed by them to be the best of their options (the other two obvious ones being to temporarily stop dealing in those securities entirely (halting buying and selling), or to continue letting people trade them as they had the previous day)? It's confusing to me.…

Citadel is a hedge fund that owns Melvin Capital Management.

Melvin is a $GME short seller predicted to lose BILLIONS due to the people taking the free market back.

Citadel owns the app Robinhood.

Citadel banned purchases of new $GME shares on RH.

Market manipulation.

https://twitter.com/shane_riordan/status/1354786445668610049

^ quoted from here

Ooops their correction here:

https://twitter.com/shane_riordan/status/1354787975058616320

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#28
post #7

Can someone who knows more about such things than I explain to me why their weird response to the situation (halting buying, but still permitting selling) was deemed by them to be the best of their options (the other two obvious ones being to temporarily stop dealing in those securities entirely (halting buying and selling), or to continue letting people trade them as they had the previous day)? It's confusing to me.…

In the simplest, likely potentially inaccurate explanation... Robinhood doesn't actually make the trades. They pay someone else to make the trades, add a small amount to the price, and that's how they get to 0$ trading price to the end user. The upstream party is refusing to do things, so Robinhood has no choice but to follow the rules that party set. That's like, way over simplified but gets to the gist [Edit cause…

Then why not communicate that in a diplomatic way. Their business and user base is at stake

Re: Robinhood now has a 1-Star rating on the Google Play Store

#29

Just as I was wondering how many retail investors might be involved: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25947674 From the number of Playstore votes it seems quite a few? Will be interesting to see if it stays that way. Or if they can somehow cheat their way out of it and get all recent ratings deleted or something. Any guesses?

My guess is that Google will get involved. It's not the first time a mob is trying to destroy the rating of an app. But their rating before all of this drama is not going to last; that's for sure.

But the app is broken. They are not allowing you to buy shares. Why should an app that decides you can't buy certain shares, and they auto-sells some shares you own, be rated highly?
Post reply on HN