Live data from Hacker News

AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

twitter.com

21–30 of 74 posts

Re: AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

#21

RobinHood had to of known this was a potential outcome or they actually have the most inept management possible. I don't know how they plan on weathering this storm given how much of a public enemy they've made themselves into overnight.

Unfortunately there is no real alternative to RH, not one which makes buying options so easy.

RH is counting on that, that only a small percentage of users will leave them.

Re: AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

#26
Very strange, I would have expected the opposite reaction. Every time people lose money on Robinhood they blame them for not screening clients appropriately, letting them invest more than their risk tolerance, etc. This is definitely abnormal, speculative conditions (i.e. anyone who is a normal buy and hold, value, income, etc investor does not need to be entering a position on those stocks right now).

Personally, I think they should have left trading open in cash accounts, but it is completely reasonable to block purchases of high risk shares especially on margin. Same as many brokerages limit OTCs, penny stocks, F shares, etc.

If someone really wants to buy more, it only takes a few minutes to open an account with another online firm. If they hadn't allowed sales and potentially prevented someone from stopping a loss that would be a much bigger deal, but for some reason AOC specifically called this out as suspicious.

Re: AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

#27

RobinHood had to of known this was a potential outcome or they actually have the most inept management possible. I don't know how they plan on weathering this storm given how much of a public enemy they've made themselves into overnight.

Such an ironic company name given the current situation.

Re: AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

#28
The ironic thing is that the end result of this will probably be a ban on payment for order flow which will destroy the commission-free trading model. We’ll go back to paying $5/trade or whatever and everyone (except HFT) will ostensibly be happy.

Re: AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

#29
post #3

The fact that Ted Cruz and AOC completely agree on this shows you how unprecedented this all is.

Yes, but... they're both wrong. The trades that Robinhood blocked were objectively bad trades, and the people they stopped from buying would almost certainly have lost all that money.

Now, I agree that there's a good first principles argument (and also a bad populist one) that people should be allowed to trade their own money into scams if they want. But the idea of proving damages here based on the idea that GME was going to CONTINUE TO GO UP after a 500% increase triggered by a short squeeze is just insane, sorry.

Re: AOC considering hearing over RobinhoodApp decision to block purchasers of GME

#30
post #8
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a super simple non partisan issue that can get him some press that isn't about his sedition

About that... https://twitter.com/AOC/status/1354848253729234944

> Ted Cruz almost had me murdered 3 weeks ago

Well not that much of a watershed moment I guess.

Post reply on HN