Live data from Hacker News

White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

phzoe.com

11–20 of 40 posts

Re: White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

#11

This website also contains climate change denial and scare quotes around the word scientist. We should be more skeptical of sites like this.

This is whataboutism and trying to discredit the researcher. Either analyse and critique the very concrete work displayed here, or don't say anything at all.

Re: White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

#14
post #4

The article implies something nefarious going on here, but there are plenty of entirely rational innocent explanations. i.e. the videos are attracting a large quantity of spam dislikes, and YouTube is bulk-removing them.

> a large quantity of spam dislikes what exactly is a 'spam dislike' . I don't see how thats a valid explanation.

Probably bots, people who do nothing but dislike videos, Indian sweatshops that are human bot farms, dislikes driven by social media posts calling for users to add dislikes, etc.

Re: White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

#15
post #6

It seems obvious there would be plenty of "legitimate" dislikes coming, as probably a lot of people who followed this YouTube channel in the past 4 years were Trump supporters, and now the channel features Biden. Trump supporters still subscribed would dislike this content. I wonder if the same happened at the last transition.

> Trump supporters still subscribed would dislike this content. I wonder if the same happened at the last transition.

Presumably you could unsubscribe. Which is not the case with instagram. If you followed the White House account, or you decide to follow the archived account for Trump, you are periodically made to follow the current White House account for Biden. Even if you block the user, it will unblock and re-follow you.

Re: White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> a large quantity of spam dislikes what exactly is a 'spam dislike' . I don't see how thats a valid explanation.

Probably bots, people who do nothing but dislike videos, Indian sweatshops that are human bot farms, dislikes driven by social media posts calling for users to add dislikes, etc.

> people who do nothing but dislike videos

> dislikes driven by social media posts calling for users to add dislikes

this is not spam. how does youtube knows which dislikes are driven by 'social media post' ?

> Indian sweatshops that are human bot farms

someone is paying sweatshops to dislike whitehouse youtube? How do you know this ?

Re: White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

#18
For a while YouTube didn’t report the exact number of views, likes and dislikes. So someone viewing a video would only getting an approximate value for each or with a deliberate small +/- offset. Is it possible that’s what’s going on here?

I find it hard to believe YT is engaging in “manipulation” of a stat that frankly doesn’t really matter if you’re an account like the White House.

Re: White House YouTube Dislike Manipulation

#20
post #4

The article implies something nefarious going on here, but there are plenty of entirely rational innocent explanations. i.e. the videos are attracting a large quantity of spam dislikes, and YouTube is bulk-removing them.

> a large quantity of spam dislikes what exactly is a 'spam dislike' . I don't see how thats a valid explanation.

One way I have seen this done in the past is that you have contest sites. As a user you gain x number of entries for every action you take. One of these actions can be to go in and like or dislike a video for example. Sometimes the sites can even check that the action was performed.

Someone wanting more entries might create lots of fake accounts.

I'm sure there are many other ways to do this but that is one example on how spam dislikes can be generated.

Post reply on HN