Live data from Hacker News

Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

laanwj.github.io

31–40 of 229 posts

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Probably the same way most people rationalize consuming the flesh of slaughtered animals, despite the massive negative environmental impact that has, and the better alternatives that are available.

Flesh of slaughtered animals is super tasty and nutritious.

[deleted]

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#33
post #17
post #2

bitcoin appears to have just become another asset that rich people on wall street are hoarding with no real attention or interest in the actual payment mechanism at all. it might as well just be some trading cards being shuffled around.

Even that is an extremely charitable interpretation. From what I can tell, Bitcoin seems largely to be an engine for fraud: fake value is injected into the system via dollar-pegged tokens like Tether, retail "investors" pile in to chase rising asset prices, and then the bottom drops out, amidst "liquidity issues" at major exchanges which prevent people from pulling out at the top. Or at least that is what happened in…

There does appear to be some evidence of this, but again, you can be an institutional fund manager and still speculating.

It's simultaneously described as a currency for exchange, a store of value and a speculative asset, but logically it cannot be all of these things simultaneously.

As an example, it fell quite sharply the other day while gold and stocks treaded water.

Is it going to $1 or $1 billion? I have no idea. But whatever is, it's certainly not reliably static.

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#34
post #17
post #2

bitcoin appears to have just become another asset that rich people on wall street are hoarding with no real attention or interest in the actual payment mechanism at all. it might as well just be some trading cards being shuffled around.

Even that is an extremely charitable interpretation. From what I can tell, Bitcoin seems largely to be an engine for fraud: fake value is injected into the system via dollar-pegged tokens like Tether, retail "investors" pile in to chase rising asset prices, and then the bottom drops out, amidst "liquidity issues" at major exchanges which prevent people from pulling out at the top. Or at least that is what happened in…

PayPal will be supporting BTC payments soon. BlackRock just announced providing exposure to BTC in some of their funds very soon.

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#36

I wonder how these Bitcoin devs rationalize the environmental impact their ongoing work has. They've created something that started as a revolutionary innovation, but by now is an incredibly wasteful way of turning kWhs into money. Something that has outlived its fitness as a payment system, but still trundles on due to its own inertia. Like oil execs that refuse to acknowledge that the age of oil is coming to a clos…

Wasteful compared to which other network that manages money and protects property rights? Most popular place to mine bitcoin is the north-west of China where there are unused hydroplants

I don’t fully understand your argument. Are you saying that a full crypto inplementation would entirely rid the World of the need for military, police, lawyers etc. or what?

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#37
I cannot recommend enough for everyone who has a minimal sensibility towards the climate impact to read this thread: https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1350869944888664064. Since we are inevitable heading over to a climate catastrophe it's really the time to advocate against bitcoin.

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#38
I don’t understand Bitcoin.

If I make bread and you grow potatoes, we can barter, but it’s much easier to use some intermediary to track the value that we exchanged. The intermediary facilitates this with tokens (coins, notes, cards.)

Bitcoin seems perverse. It puts all the value in the tokens themselves and at the same time I can’t even use it to buy bread or potatoes.

About the only thing I hear that you can buy with Bitcoin is USD, and even the liquidity of that seems questionable beyond a certain amount — the millions maybe but probably not billions.

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#39
It's a nice post, but it is a shame that the author does not mention certain current controversy [0] where Bitcoin Core has crumpled like a wet paper bag under a thread of lawsuit by one Craig Steven Wright - one that he played a key role in [1].

The PR to revert that change is still open and locked [2] so I can only imagine what kind of direct messages he would be receiving - I doubt many of them would be what one would consider 'nice'. Not to mention any of it when stepping back seems a little incredulous.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25858901

[1] https://github.com/bitcoin-core/bitcoincore.org/pull/740

[2] https://github.com/bitcoin-core/bitcoincore.org/pull/744

Re: Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decentralization

#40

I wonder how these Bitcoin devs rationalize the environmental impact their ongoing work has. They've created something that started as a revolutionary innovation, but by now is an incredibly wasteful way of turning kWhs into money. Something that has outlived its fitness as a payment system, but still trundles on due to its own inertia. Like oil execs that refuse to acknowledge that the age of oil is coming to a clos…

No rationalization needed. It is all bs. "Greenest" car is Tesla that burns 15 kg of coal per 100km.

Crypto dev since 2014.

Post reply on HN