Live data from Hacker News

Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

hisham.hm

21–30 of 333 posts

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#21

This seems to fly directly against recently articles about the massive uptick in iOS customisation after 14 launched. The #ios14homescreen hashtag on Twitter seems extremely popular: https://twitter.com/hashtag/ios14homescreen

How does it fly against it? To me it appears to say "well of course that's popular, the configurability gives users a sense of ownership over their device"

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#22
I think what UI customization shows us is that software vendors providing customize-ability correlates with a lack of confidence in the defaults they ship.

When someone creating software has a strong opinion about the "right" way, they can't see the possibility that anyone would ever have legit disagreement with their brilliance so they take away control. And when they can't figure out the right solution to something, they ship flexibility so it can be the user's fault that it works like shit.

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#23
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Windows 10 has themes now too

Except that Windows 10 themes are a severe security/malware hazard, not a customization of harmless graphical elements.

Eh? Windows 10 themes are just wallpaper packs and a defined accent color.

I assume you’re referring to UxStyle etc as used since Windows XP? That doesn’t involve loading any executable code (unless there’s an RCE vulnerability in the theme resource loader, I suppose) - patching the signature checks in UxTheme.dll isn’t that big a deal, imo.

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#24

This seems to fly directly against recently articles about the massive uptick in iOS customisation after 14 launched. The #ios14homescreen hashtag on Twitter seems extremely popular: https://twitter.com/hashtag/ios14homescreen

The post is from mid-2019. I think the development you mention tallies very well with how the post ends.

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#25
I wish there were real high-quality Linux and Windows themes imitating Windows 3.x, 98 and XP (and some other old OSes perhaps) realistically, not just "kind of like that". I would even pay money for such if I were satisfied.

Ideally, they should also be easy to combine in different ways. E.g. I want Win3.11 pixel art icons, Win98 window&panel styles and WinXP non-antialiased fonts - these 3 things make me feel orgasmic.

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#26

> Remember changing colours on the computer? You can do that in Windows 10. It can also change automatically based on your current wallpaper. Similarly to installing Nova Launcher, perhaps the author need to use GNU/Linux or Windows instead of a Mac.

Not quite. You can set an Accent color and either a light or dark background - that’s it. You can’t specify each component color or named system color - such as separately specifying the colors of the scrollbar’ track and thumb - or icon text - or button shadows - and so on. The old “Desktop Themes” feature for Windows 95 Plus! and Windows 98 let the user radically change the appearance of Windows - for better or for…

Yep, I remember that game well: switch to Hog Dog Stand, then see how long you can tolerate it before eyeball bleed forces you to revert.

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#27
When I first started playing around with OS X the appearance section of the control panel seemed unfinished, and I naively hoped they would add more color options in a future update. Nope, just aqua or grey!

At the time I'd been using Internet Explorer for Mac and really wanted to see the color-configurable interface happen system-wide. I thought it made sense to let people set their interface colors to match the fruit of their iMac if they wanted, since you could do that in OS 8 and 9. Eventually the computers themselves lost color/individuality as well.

Re: Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment

#29

I think what UI customization shows us is that software vendors providing customize-ability correlates with a lack of confidence in the defaults they ship. When someone creating software has a strong opinion about the "right" way, they can't see the possibility that anyone would ever have legit disagreement with their brilliance so they take away control. And when they can't figure out the right solution to something…

Or they have moved to the next level up and seen one size does not fit all?
Post reply on HN