Live data from Hacker News

RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

articles.boston.com

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#11
From "Soul":

There’s no such thing as a perfect design. Most experienced computer engineers I talked to agreed that absorbing this simple lesson constitutes the first step in learning how to get machines out the door. Often, they said, it is the most talented engineers who have the hardest time learning when to stop striving for perfection. West was the voice from the cave, supplying that information: “Ok. It’s right. Ship it.”

He would bind his team with mutual trust, he had decided. When a person signed up to do a job for him, he would in turn trust that person to accomplish it; he wouldn’t break it down into little pieces and make the task small, easy and dull.

With Tom, it’s the last two percent that counts. What I now call ‘the ability to ship product’ — to get it out the door.

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#13
RIP Tom, thanks for being an inspiration to me as a very young child. Soul Of A New Machine had a place on my father's bookshelf right next to The C Programming language. I might not work in the industry today if I hadn't been so stricken by Kidder's description of your work ethic.

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#14
post #8

Damn, I had the opportunity to use some Data General Machines in the 1980s..fine machines, reliable, etc... I am the only older one here that remembers using the machines?

I used an MV/8000 ("Eagle") when I was writing video game cartridges for Atari. I never really programmed it -- maybe a little scripting in their shell -- but just used it for cross-development to some home computers. The system rarely crashed.

I was used to 4.2 bsd, but the DG was still a nice system. It got bogged down during the day with 40-50 users running an awful little email and office automation app, but it was fine at night (just like the mainframe at my university).

The shell struck me as a cross between VAX/VMS and Unix. The file system was pretty decent. The screen editor that DG provided worked well, and though I missed Emacs, it was adequate for writing largish programs. (There was a DG equivalent of TECO that I tried to learn, but it was about as opaque and terse ("badly designed") as the original TECO and I just gave it up after a while).

All in all, I was pleasantly surprised with how well it worked.

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#15
Sorry to hear this. I read this book as a kid and it has had a pronounced influence on my life and career. Never had a chance to work on any of the systems, but the ideas and excitement around the technical guts of the system inspired me.

/me raises a glass in toast.

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#16
"Soul of a New Machine" was practically required reading when I was at Convex (where Steve Wallach, interviewed for the article, went to be CTO post-DG.)

To say that the culture of Mostek and DG influenced Convex would be gross understatement.

I learned a lot at my first "real job" in the industry. I've never found anyplace as "good" to work since. (Nor am I alone in expressing this.)

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#18
I posted this a few days ago, but it sunk like a stone. I'm glad to see it getting the attention here it deserves.

I met Tom a number of times-- I'm friends with his daughter-- and he was a hell of a guy. I'm glad the obit mentioned a few of his non-IT related adventures...

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#19

RIP, Mr. West. I read the Kidder book in high-school, and it was definitely a factor that motivated me to get involved with computers and this industry. Feeling a tinge of nostalgia, I went back and re-read it a few months ago... and found that it stands the test of time well. It's a very interesting read, even if the technology has moved on considerably since the Data General days. And I still wish I'd had the chanc…

For me, that book will always mark the standard for technical journalism. Compare the depth of research of the Kidder book to today's techcrunch, or any of the dozens of books written about Google and you can see how far this generation of journalists have yet to go.

This Wired article (from about 10 years ago) tells a bit about Tracy Kidder's working methods (and quite a bit more about Tom West):

http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.12/soul.html

Re: RIP: Tom West (Data General, "Soul of a New Machine")

#20
Tom West captured the essence of what motivates me to work, and what I find motivates most of the incredible people I've had the opportunity to work with:

An engineer's essential desire, after all, is to design and build a machine and see it through to completion, but completion itself is therefore not the ultimate reward. In the Eagle days, West called this paradox "pinball." In pinball, he reasoned, the prize for winning is getting to play again. The story of the Eagle engineers since Soul is one of a career-length version of pinball.

Post reply on HN