Live data from Hacker News

A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

github.com

31–40 of 80 posts

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#31
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its a Nintendo DS Game that has grown a cult following ever since the first game was released. A visual novel style game.

Actually the original series is from Game Boy Advance, but the GBA games were never released outside of Japan. Nintendo DS ports were the first one releases in the rest of the world. BTW, I am a great fan of the series, really recommend it.

Did you know that it's actually a rather pointed parody/criticism of the Japanese justice system? I had no idea myself! Perhaps I was the only one who didn't know.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Jap...

The conviction rate in Japan is over 99% -- going to "trial" is essentially the same as being found guilty.

The prosecuting attorneys have a lot of discretion over what is prosecuted, and are effectively de facto judges. They may decide to simply not prosecute a case if they feel "character, age, environment, gravity of the offense, circumstances or situation after the offense" makes it unnecessary.

So it's easy to imagine there might be some with quite an ego like Edgeworth or Von Karma -- and a protagonist like our heroic defense attorney would be quite the unusual attorney, indeed! I loved the games even without knowing any of that, but that really makes them all the more poignant and funny for me.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#32
post #3

Fun. Reminds me of Comic Chat. Maybe we need a Slack app to make these images for each message? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Comic_Chat

I used to get kicked out everytime I converted a group to comic chat. Those were the days :)

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#33
The first Ace Attorney game must have been incredible value for Capcom's investment. The spartan, comic-like sprites and straightforward visual novel gameplay likely fit into a smaller ROM size. Given the charming narrative, I bet they made their ROI pretty quickly in the first print run.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#34
I've wondered if the AI superintelligence everyone is watching out for is actually slowly being built from the bottom up, and encompasses evening in the entire world. Deep Thought from Hitchhiker's Guide is seeming more and more plausible to me. Perhaps this bot that makes Reddit videos doesn't do anything "useful" per se, but it is doing what a human might otherwise do, and adds itself to Reddit as an entity that could be indistinguishable from a person making silly videos.

What percentage of Reddit comments are bots? I'd be curious to know. SaaS and Lambda functions and and APIs are all like very complicated neurons that link together to form this world wide web of interactions.

I've wondered if an approach to the AI alignment problem is really to see that the entirety of all the computers in the world are a giant brain that is continually self-improving. Phoenix Wright bot is one neuron, like any other. And so to align the world AI, you have to align the culture that makes the AI. And so, basically, anything that one does to improve the culture in a sense improves AI.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#35
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually the original series is from Game Boy Advance, but the GBA games were never released outside of Japan. Nintendo DS ports were the first one releases in the rest of the world. BTW, I am a great fan of the series, really recommend it.

Did you know that it's actually a rather pointed parody/criticism of the Japanese justice system? I had no idea myself! Perhaps I was the only one who didn't know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Jap... The conviction rate in Japan is over 99% -- going to "trial" is essentially the same as being found guilty. The prosecuting attorneys have a lot of discretion over what is prosecuted, and are…

I recently started playing it on the Switch, and my first thought was that I hope the Japanese court system isn't really like this. It makes me appreciate the idea of "innocent until proven guilty" in the US. Ace Attorney feels much more "I don't like you, so I'm going to assume you're guilty unless you have absolute proof that you're not".

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#38
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you know that it's actually a rather pointed parody/criticism of the Japanese justice system? I had no idea myself! Perhaps I was the only one who didn't know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Jap... The conviction rate in Japan is over 99% -- going to "trial" is essentially the same as being found guilty. The prosecuting attorneys have a lot of discretion over what is prosecuted, and are…

I recently started playing it on the Switch, and my first thought was that I hope the Japanese court system isn't really like this. It makes me appreciate the idea of "innocent until proven guilty" in the US. Ace Attorney feels much more "I don't like you, so I'm going to assume you're guilty unless you have absolute proof that you're not".

Justice systems are complicated. From what I've read, it's true that the japanese court system indeed gives prosecutors more leeway and the trial is more of a formality. The conviction rate of 99% (vs 70-95% in the us, depending how you count) speaks to this.

However, that's not all there is to it. You're still innocent until proven guilty in Japan.

There's also probably more in common with the japanese justice system and the US system than different. In practice, the majority of cases in both don't go to trial. In japan, the prosecution will just not prosecute any case they don't think they'll win (and have broad leeway to do so). This results in a 99% conviction rate because, well, there's no reason they can't just drop any case without rock solid evidence. Even in cases where they're confident the suspect is guilty, but they don't think they have enough evidence, they may opt to just drop the case.

In the US, similarly, most cases don't go to trial. The vast majority are also ended under prosecutor discretion, via plea bargains. Both in the US and Japan, most cases skip the proper court system due to the prosecution having power to do so. It's just in Japan, the prosecution also has power to drop the case, while in the US the prosecution can only skip the courts if they get a plea deal, but not if the suspect keeps pleading not-guilty.

Japan has laws requiring evidence in addition to a confession due to understanding that police sometimes force confessions (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Jap...)

In america it's routine for people to be convicted on nothing other than a suspect agreeing to a plea deal even though they didn't do it. "You can get 1 year in jail and get back to your family if you take the plea, or you can risk 30 years in jail if you keep saying not-guilty" isn't at all unusual in the US system, especially since a cop's word is often enough for a guilty sentence.

I'd be happy to be wrong on any of he above details if anyone has separate experience, understanding, or sources.

All that being said, I'd much much rather be arrested in Japan than in the US.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#39

Actually, if there was something that turned a thread into speech, that I could listen to while doing work around the house, might be useful.

Pocket does Text to Speech, IIRC. I think I tried it on reddit at some point. It turns out the ability to just skip comments and not read through all the threads in their entirety is pretty important.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#40
post #26

People also do this manually via objection.lol. One of my favourites is "All odd numbers have an E in them" [1]. [1]: https://youtu.be/IFcyYnUHVBA

"Is Lava Wet" is art. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWF_8dw0zdQ

Also notable: "Is soup a drink?"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IDNuz_VFJtU

Post reply on HN