Live data from Hacker News

The Tragedy of Gemini

maya.land

1–10 of 30 posts

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#2
digital frontiers fold ever inward. gemini is a little secret nook carved out behind the clubhouse in the corner of a hidden cul-de-sac of a massive global labyrinth. there's no wall, it's just hard to find unless you know the way. there's no tragedy, it's just not everybody chooses to walk the paths you chose to walk.

we're all running away from everyone forever. it's okay. that's the point. when we get out here we find the people like us.

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#3
post #2

digital frontiers fold ever inward. gemini is a little secret nook carved out behind the clubhouse in the corner of a hidden cul-de-sac of a massive global labyrinth. there's no wall, it's just hard to find unless you know the way. there's no tragedy, it's just not everybody chooses to walk the paths you chose to walk. we're all running away from everyone forever. it's okay. that's the point. when we get out here we…

Do you only want to hear from people like you? To only make your community with people like you?

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#4
In that sense, being accustomed to cli and able to use gemini is no different than community of people who plays Go, Shogi or fan of Liverpool football team pre 2000. I’m not entirely sure being not too popular is a reason to be sad — not everyone needs to be Real Madrid fan

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#5
post #3
post #2

digital frontiers fold ever inward. gemini is a little secret nook carved out behind the clubhouse in the corner of a hidden cul-de-sac of a massive global labyrinth. there's no wall, it's just hard to find unless you know the way. there's no tragedy, it's just not everybody chooses to walk the paths you chose to walk. we're all running away from everyone forever. it's okay. that's the point. when we get out here we…

Do you only want to hear from people like you? To only make your community with people like you?

A lot of time, yes. If I’m looking for movies recommendation, I would try to find people who are most similar to me.

Also, no one is using Gemini exclusively, the web still exists

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#6
post #3
post #2

digital frontiers fold ever inward. gemini is a little secret nook carved out behind the clubhouse in the corner of a hidden cul-de-sac of a massive global labyrinth. there's no wall, it's just hard to find unless you know the way. there's no tragedy, it's just not everybody chooses to walk the paths you chose to walk. we're all running away from everyone forever. it's okay. that's the point. when we get out here we…

Do you only want to hear from people like you? To only make your community with people like you?

> from people like you

What constitutes someone like me?

I absolutely mostly want to hear from people with similar attributes to me, similar fundamental guiding principles about what makes someone good or bad, and so on, but I'd also like to hear from people with very different experiences to me. I don't think these are especially incompatible ideas

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#8
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you only want to hear from people like you? To only make your community with people like you?

> from people like you What constitutes someone like me? I absolutely mostly want to hear from people with similar attributes to me, similar fundamental guiding principles about what makes someone good or bad, and so on, but I'd also like to hear from people with very different experiences to me. I don't think these are especially incompatible ideas

Well, in this case, "someone like me" is enforced by technical abstruseness as meaning someone who knows their way around a shell prompt. That's value-neutral in of itself, but you can see how it ends up selecting for certain views on the world

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#9
post #4

In that sense, being accustomed to cli and able to use gemini is no different than community of people who plays Go, Shogi or fan of Liverpool football team pre 2000. I’m not entirely sure being not too popular is a reason to be sad — not everyone needs to be Real Madrid fan

A boomer would find your comment curious. Before Manchester United struck gold with the Class of ‘92, Liverpool were the automatic favorites every year and dominated the English league for more than a decade, accumulating plenty of glory-hunter supporters. Obviously they shrunk in the Premier League era after a series of bad years, but they’ve always had one of the largest and most insufferable fanbases.

Re: The Tragedy of Gemini

#10
Exclusivity and elitism get a bad rap. The most important ingredient for a high-quality community is high-quality people, and to keep out the lower-quality people you need to have barriers to entry. I suspect that most Gemini users are smart enough to realise that, whether they'd admit it or not.
Post reply on HN