Live data from Hacker News

If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

critter.blog

231–240 of 329 posts

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#232
post #213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unlike the Outlook+Exchange combination Sieve is an actual open standard (RFC 5228 & RFC 5804 & co) though that can be implemented by all mail servers and mail clients. Or is the Outlook+Exchange feature based on the same? Looking at the sieve website it seems quite a few desktop and web mail clients do have support for it either out of the box or as an add-on. So I would say that having this functionality is more on…

Exchange rules configured through Outlook are omnipresent . Sieve might be supported by many email clients, but is pretty much nonexistent in corporate email. Actually, if someone points me to one hosted email provider that does support it, I'd be glad - I was wondering about trying it out but nobody supports it.

I recently switched some of my email addresses to Migadu. I haven't tested it yet but they apparently offer Sieve support.

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#234

I find this somewhat incomprehensible. Why the bias for seeing and archiving everything? The implicit model, which is right there in his title, is "talk", which is not naturally archived. I've built products just fine using verbal communication nearly exclusively. [1] We don't need to create some sort of panoptic archive of every conversation ever had to get things done. If people miss things, they miss things. We ca…

Talk was not naturally archived in the past, but I would not assume that today. There is no longer anything that is an intimate object, pretty much anything can have a microphone and some type of wireless connection. Is your desk phone at the office listening to you even though it's on the hook? Technically it can. What about your smart TV?

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#235

I disagree with this article. This is what was said about GMail when it first came out - you need folders, without folders you can't keep organized, etc. Turns out indexing and mechanisms to make use of that indexing (labels, advanced sorts, filters) work better than folders. Persistent chat that can be labelled, indexed, searched and filtered is amazing for work related chats, or any chat that becomes part of a long…

The sheer volume of information that Chat holds makes it hard to search. The noise to signal ratio is higher than on channels with lower throughout (e.g. documentation products). Chat doesn't let you send one message and craft it over time, like a mission statement, proposal, or architecture guide. It has a fundamentally different character.

And some chats are worse than others. Teams does this so poorly it brings my battlestation to its knees trying to do simple text search.

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’d like to see email clients offer a nice one-click “rebase on top of latest” button.

Dang. I never thought of email like that, but I wonder if email+git+UI would help for complex conversations.

You should look at the git mailing list. They actually send patches via email using the git format-patch and git send-email commands and have complex discussions around some of the patches.

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#237
Teams trying to enforce conversation threading in a (semi-)recent update pretty much put a halt to me and my coworkers using Teams for anything but voice for our morning sprints. Trying to follow even slow conversations in Teams is just way too much work, we instead chat on Telegram where chat works, you know, normally.

Luckily we were never in the habit of tracking anything through chat, we stick to our issue tracker, but I can absolutely imagine the frustration we'd have felt after that change had we relied more heavily on chat.

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#238
Okay, but what about real time search history? That’s not mentioned as a key. feature in the article.

That’s the whole point of not worrying about these lines without sufficient thought.

Being able to query the past instanteously via live chats is vital.

I see live transcripts via iMessage and live chats as a huge benefit — your thoughts in real time, basically, shared externally without energy wasted verbally.

One of my biggest regrets is not pro-actively hitting aim support right before mass account deletion post mortem acquisition by Verizon.

Imagine scrolling back in time to your high school chats— one can easily use that context to go back in time like Mac OS time machine.

Put all of those time stamps in whatever format (t, chat service, message) on a visual calendar and you’ll be able to do much more with your data. Including attachments.

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#239
post #238

Okay, but what about real time search history? That’s not mentioned as a key. feature in the article. That’s the whole point of not worrying about these lines without sufficient thought. Being able to query the past instanteously via live chats is vital. I see live transcripts via iMessage and live chats as a huge benefit — your thoughts in real time, basically, shared externally without energy wasted verbally. One o…

My hope is most of my youthful chats have been forever destroyed. It's not a season I'd like to revisit.

Re: If it will matter after today, don't talk about it in a chat room

#240
post #238

Okay, but what about real time search history? That’s not mentioned as a key. feature in the article. That’s the whole point of not worrying about these lines without sufficient thought. Being able to query the past instanteously via live chats is vital. I see live transcripts via iMessage and live chats as a huge benefit — your thoughts in real time, basically, shared externally without energy wasted verbally. One o…

hitting aim support for what? afaik they weren’t holding onto aim chats. tho my memory is fuzzy here
Post reply on HN