Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

news.ycombinator.com

1–10 of 21 posts

Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#1
I'm marking up a page right now, have a list of Twitter users to link to and am debating the use of target="_blank" without an explicit "new tab/window" icon.

I personally have no use for this anymore. If I am browsing a webpage and I want the link to open in a new tab I will do it myself, otherwise I expect it to open in the same tab.

How do others feel about this?

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#2
I hate it when websites do this, because it overrides the expected behavior of the browser with the author's desires. People who want each link to open in a new tab/window know about Ctrl-Click or Right-Click+Open-in-new-window. They can do it themselves if they desire. For everyone else, this is rude, annoying, and breaks the back button.

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#3

I hate it when websites do this, because it overrides the expected behavior of the browser with the author's desires. People who want each link to open in a new tab/window know about Ctrl-Click or Right-Click+Open-in-new-window. They can do it themselves if they desire. For everyone else, this is rude, annoying, and breaks the back button.

Totally agree.

It seems like a convention that exists for sites that want to force the user into their content even when they want to leave. Unless it is a file download link - I find it incredibly rude.

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#4

I hate it when websites do this, because it overrides the expected behavior of the browser with the author's desires. People who want each link to open in a new tab/window know about Ctrl-Click or Right-Click+Open-in-new-window. They can do it themselves if they desire. For everyone else, this is rude, annoying, and breaks the back button.

You forgot the famous third-click. Ctrl or cmd click or right click seems... too much work lol

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#5
post #4

I hate it when websites do this, because it overrides the expected behavior of the browser with the author's desires. People who want each link to open in a new tab/window know about Ctrl-Click or Right-Click+Open-in-new-window. They can do it themselves if they desire. For everyone else, this is rude, annoying, and breaks the back button.

You forgot the famous third-click. Ctrl or cmd click or right click seems... too much work lol

Ever since I found out about the amazing middle click function, I manage to stack up probably 50-60 tabs by the end of everyday. It's hard to imagine how we managed back when there were no tabs on browsers.

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#6
I think using it is still appropriate when you know the user isn't intending to really leave the page they're on.

For example, clicking on a help link (while filling out a screen) or anything else that would disrupt what the user's doing unintentionally.

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#7
post #6

I think using it is still appropriate when you know the user isn't intending to really leave the page they're on. For example, clicking on a help link (while filling out a screen) or anything else that would disrupt what the user's doing unintentionally.

I agree. I think sometimes it's okay when you're sure that the user wouldn't want to browse away from the page they are on... such as when filling out a form or maybe even watching a tutorial video. Otherwise, I think it should be left up to the user.

Personally I tend to use it for links like "follow us on twitter" because I'm hoping that they will keep both tabs open. However the comments here are making me wonder if that's too forceful.

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#8

I hate it when websites do this, because it overrides the expected behavior of the browser with the author's desires. People who want each link to open in a new tab/window know about Ctrl-Click or Right-Click+Open-in-new-window. They can do it themselves if they desire. For everyone else, this is rude, annoying, and breaks the back button.

Has Google ever done a study to see how many people know about opening a link in a new window/tab?

They must have, right?

Based on my experience it's very much less than half of normal people know how to do this.

Re: Ask HN: target="_blank" thoughts?

#9
post #5
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You forgot the famous third-click. Ctrl or cmd click or right click seems... too much work lol

Ever since I found out about the amazing middle click function, I manage to stack up probably 50-60 tabs by the end of everyday. It's hard to imagine how we managed back when there were no tabs on browsers.

same boat here. i gotta groom tabs a few times a day, save sessions, save a bazillion bookmarks and my browsers still chow down memory!
Post reply on HN