Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

newsweek.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 234 posts

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#21

Post by megameter »

harmmonica wrote: post #6

This would be whack-a-mole otherwise, but when I saw this trending the vast majority of the tweets were sharing videos of people chanting that slogan in the Capitol amidst the storm. By suppressing the sharing of that information people are actually less likely to be aware that's what they were chanting (I know I would be less aware because that's where I learned about it). Now I guess there's the potential they were…

Even in a low level sense, this is an inherent calculation to the doing of moderation. If you let a hot button issue be spoken of freely, it dominates the timeline. If you cut it out, something else becomes the topic in its place, but that can actually help with discussing the issue by forcing it to be addressed only indirectly, linked into a larger narrative, instead of with reactive side-taking.

Blocking the trend, in this instance, is different from blocking the speech.

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#22

Post by slg »

st1x7 wrote: post #5

It's kind of sad to see how these threads quickly turn into a a messy sequence of poorly reasoned arguments or how some people are trying to justify really extreme positions.

It is interesting that this comment is written in a specifically vague way so no one can tell if the "extreme position" you are talking about is hanging the sitting VP or censoring social media. Therefore lots of people are going to upvote this thinking you are on their side and it is the other side that uses "poorly reasoned arguments" to defend their "really extreme positions."

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#24

Post by kerng »

corytheboyd wrote: post #3

Good. Calls for violence are unacceptable.

It was more about documenting what happened a few days ago and what intentions the rioters had. That context is lacking and should have been provided by Twitter right away when making it "trending".

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#25

Post by npunt »

On a good day like a third of twitter's trending topics are people saying "I can't believe this is a trending topic".

Irrespective of that there's a certain authority imbued with words listed in a trending topics section, whether or not the user clicks on them. Since trending topics lack context, there's a literalism to them that can distort meaning.

As much of this was about a reaction to the video rather than a literal interpretation, it would probably be best to reword it with more context or make it a news item, if it's to remain up at all.

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#26

Post by mcphage »

45t3424rgf wrote: post #18
trianglem wrote: post #8

These people are a lost cause. There was a vicious attack on an unassuming black woman in LA yesterday where more than 20 trump supporters held her down and punched and maced her. These people are terrorists and should be dealt with accordingly.

So? Just because a few people did something unacceptable doesn't all of them are like this. A while back a child got killed named Cannon Hinnant by a black person for no reason does that mean we should label all blacks as a terrorist?

And what happened to the killer?

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#27

Post by petschge »

tester756 wrote: post #19

I considered trying to get visa to USA and work there, but honestly last year makes me really worried about living there is it safe to live there?

Depends very much where in the US. And to some extend how you look, how you talk and what your gender is. The overwhelmingly large majority to places is safe. But every large enough city has unsavory places that need at least being aware of what (not) to do. But that is similar in a lot of countries.

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#28

Post by corytheboyd »

kerng wrote: post #24
corytheboyd wrote: post #3

Good. Calls for violence are unacceptable.

It was more about documenting what happened a few days ago and what intentions the rioters had. That context is lacking and should have been provided by Twitter right away when making it "trending".

“Hang Mike Pence” is a call for violence.

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#29

Post by CPLX »

dmode wrote: post #23

Why would a Trump supporter want to “hang Mike Pence” when he has been loyal to him for 4 years and just did his constitutional duty on the 6th ? I am lost for words

Worth noting that sudden executions of the number two in command is a pretty common occurrence in authoritarian government situations.

Re: Twitter Confirms It Halted 'Hang Mike Pence' as a Trending Topic

#30

Post by virtual_void »

45t3424rgf wrote: post #18
trianglem wrote: post #8

These people are a lost cause. There was a vicious attack on an unassuming black woman in LA yesterday where more than 20 trump supporters held her down and punched and maced her. These people are terrorists and should be dealt with accordingly.

So? Just because a few people did something unacceptable doesn't all of them are like this. A while back a child got killed named Cannon Hinnant by a black person for no reason does that mean we should label all blacks as a terrorist?

When people use violence in the name of a cause then i think the cap fits.

Also i think you’re making a false equivalence here. There is a not insignificant fraction of them willing to be violent because because they either don’t (or don’t want to) understand how democracy works.

I think it’s fine to lump those people together as domestic terrorists.

Post reply on HN