Live data from Hacker News

We need more than deplatforming

blog.mozilla.org

1–10 of 83 posts

Re: We need more than deplatforming

#2
> By all means the question of when to deplatform a head of state is a critical one

Indeed. Maybe communications platforms, even private ones, should be carved out of the general ability to deny service. We have similar notions already, e.g., libel plaintiffs who are public figures must prove malice.

Even if one disagrees with whatever that communication is, we should recognize that stifling it, even when done by a private entity and not the state, sows distrust.

Re: We need more than deplatforming

#5
I really don't recognize the society that we are moving towards. People are welcoming censorship with open arms. Twitter and other social media are the public spaces of the internet. Deplatforming someone there is essentially as if the governments bans the public speech of someone in the "real" world.

It truly gives me shivers down my spine...

Re: We need more than deplatforming

#6

I really don't recognize the society that we are moving towards. People are welcoming censorship with open arms. Twitter and other social media are the public spaces of the internet. Deplatforming someone there is essentially as if the governments bans the public speech of someone in the "real" world. It truly gives me shivers down my spine...

The Mozilla blog post you are replying about is suggesting increasing transparency, not suggesting more censorship.

Re: We need more than deplatforming

#8
post #6

I really don't recognize the society that we are moving towards. People are welcoming censorship with open arms. Twitter and other social media are the public spaces of the internet. Deplatforming someone there is essentially as if the governments bans the public speech of someone in the "real" world. It truly gives me shivers down my spine...

The Mozilla blog post you are replying about is suggesting increasing transparency , not suggesting more censorship.

Yes and that's good. But it's also very much pro censorship.

Re: We need more than deplatforming

#9
post #6

I really don't recognize the society that we are moving towards. People are welcoming censorship with open arms. Twitter and other social media are the public spaces of the internet. Deplatforming someone there is essentially as if the governments bans the public speech of someone in the "real" world. It truly gives me shivers down my spine...

The Mozilla blog post you are replying about is suggesting increasing transparency , not suggesting more censorship.

You're being quite glib if you're honestly pretending not to see the glaring subtext there. The intention is obviously to increase transparency in order to stamp out unwanted opinions before they even spread.
Post reply on HN