Live data from Hacker News

Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

torrentfreak.com

11–20 of 280 posts

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#11
post #4

Rights holders have been trying to get rid of sites like the pirate bay for more than a decade, and if anything PB is easier to find and more reliable to use than ever before. If they really want change, it's time for them to dispassionately consider their situation. The way to "beat" piracy is to consider it as a competitor, which it is. When I was a kid, everyone downloaded raw mp3s and now that number is a fractio…

We screwed content makers with mp3s, which allowed publishers to follow suit. We changed the paradigm. This is a bit harder because schools pay for content not the researchers directly. It’ll be harder to force change.

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#12
post #5
post #2

I can't imagine some working on banning sci hub and thinking it's "a good thing".

Why? For somebody not familiar with how research publishing works it might just look like xeroxing books.

> somebody not familiar with how research publishing

Yeah and not able to use google about his own work.. The debate is pretty clearly explained everywhere.

That said I have, more controversially, the same opinion about movie piracy. In general don't understand how you can feel good defending Goliath vs David. (The cinema industry never earnt so much money so far, at least pre-covid).

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#13

Will the new American administration (I'm not an American and should have no bone on American politics, but this is how the world works) will significantly enable Twitbookgle to exert powers they did not under Trumpism?

What powers did they not exert during the Trump administration?

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#17
Let’s suppose sci-hub distributes unauthorized content. It’s still not counterfeit. In the physical world I believe this is called the grey market.

It’s legit, just not via official distribution channels.

Anyhow, another case of Twitter capriciously moderating content and quelling free speech. The worst part though is that Twitter HQ sets the policy to whatever suits their fancy. They are not beholden to their users or any other oversight.

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#18

Will the new American administration (I'm not an American and should have no bone on American politics, but this is how the world works) will significantly enable Twitbookgle to exert powers they did not under Trumpism?

What powers did they not exert during the Trump administration?

Trump repeatedly chastised them for their censorship policies and the threat of additional legislation was always over their head. Now that the politicians in power are the ones allied with the tech giants, there's little stopping them (the tech giants) from going full 1984.

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#19

Will the new American administration (I'm not an American and should have no bone on American politics, but this is how the world works) will significantly enable Twitbookgle to exert powers they did not under Trumpism?

What limits did Trump admin put on them? They bullied them into up weighting Conservative content and down weighting Liberal content but I doubt that changes.

https://www.motherjones.com/media/2020/10/facebook-mother-jo...

Re: Sci-Hub Founder Criticizes Sudden Twitter Ban over “Counterfeit” Content

#20

Will the new American administration (I'm not an American and should have no bone on American politics, but this is how the world works) will significantly enable Twitbookgle to exert powers they did not under Trumpism?

What powers did they not exert during the Trump administration?

That's exactly my question: are they going to acquire new powers that we didn't know existed?
Post reply on HN