Live data from Hacker News

URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

ylukem.com

91–100 of 213 posts

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is a shame that T.LY displays only the footer without JavaScript enabled instead of degrading gracefully. Surely a plain HTML form that POSTs should suffice? I'm not sure how much work it would require for you to support this, but it would help cement your place as a good web actor if you're so inclined!

Sorry about that. I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? We do offer a simple to use api that you could build on top of to shorten link. Also an extension that offers the ability to shorten a url in one click. API Docs: https://t.ly/docs/ Extension: https://t.ly/extension

I use u-block origin on "medium" mode where you have it block 3rd party javascript by default and it behaves the same. Unblocking the cloudflare originating javascript fixes it. I'd guess my setup is more common than having javascript disabled entirely. Not a complaint, just another data point.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#92
cookie dropping is more common than people realize.

I've created a free service with no ads and completely free that also generates qrcodes (https://qrli.to)

The problem with url shortners is usually the abuse they get (from affiliate tracking above to MLM or CPL for dating sites). However the entry barrier is so low and they are still a relevant part of the infrastructure, not surprised bitly and tinyurl are monetizing this way.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Seems nice. I'm curious, how do you make money / stay in business? I couldn't find any paid options.

Thank you! The site and extension are free to use to shorten links. I do offer the ability to upgrade starting at $5 a month which allows custom domains, ability to customize links, expire links based on date or clicks, private stats, ability to shorten links using the API ( https://t.ly/docs/ ). I also recently release a new feature called OneLinks that are great for social media bios. Here is an example on a OneLin…

Hmmm. My browser complained that you’re running three trackers on that site (google, cloudflare and digital ocean).

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry about that. I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? We do offer a simple to use api that you could build on top of to shorten link. Also an extension that offers the ability to shorten a url in one click. API Docs: https://t.ly/docs/ Extension: https://t.ly/extension

I use u-block origin on "medium" mode where you have it block 3rd party javascript by default and it behaves the same. Unblocking the cloudflare originating javascript fixes it. I'd guess my setup is more common than having javascript disabled entirely. Not a complaint, just another data point.

Yes I do have the site behind cloudflare but could remove the javascript rocket loader feature. I will look into this. Thanks for sharing!

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry about that. I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? We do offer a simple to use api that you could build on top of to shorten link. Also an extension that offers the ability to shorten a url in one click. API Docs: https://t.ly/docs/ Extension: https://t.ly/extension

>I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? Not the person you asked, but speaking for myself, all the time. I have a javascript toggle I use several times a day, and leave it set to off as much as I can.

Interesting..How many sites work without javascript these days? Does google?

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#96
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you! The site and extension are free to use to shorten links. I do offer the ability to upgrade starting at $5 a month which allows custom domains, ability to customize links, expire links based on date or clicks, private stats, ability to shorten links using the API ( https://t.ly/docs/ ). I also recently release a new feature called OneLinks that are great for social media bios. Here is an example on a OneLin…

Hmmm. My browser complained that you’re running three trackers on that site (google, cloudflare and digital ocean).

Are you seriously equating "has an image hosted on digitalocean" (which probably hosts the entire site) with "tracking"?

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#97
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thank you! The site and extension are free to use to shorten links. I do offer the ability to upgrade starting at $5 a month which allows custom domains, ability to customize links, expire links based on date or clicks, private stats, ability to shorten links using the API ( https://t.ly/docs/ ). I also recently release a new feature called OneLinks that are great for social media bios. Here is an example on a OneLin…

Hmmm. My browser complained that you’re running three trackers on that site (google, cloudflare and digital ocean).

Yes cloudflare for speed and protection. Digitalocean for file storage. I may remove google analytics.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#98
post #82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tried in a new profile and didn't see any viglink.com. Edit: the link should be https://tinyurl.com/examplezoom (which does have viglink.com). For some reason you wrote the preview link, https://preview.tinyurl.com/examplezoom , which does not have the tracker.

I think that's their point: preview.tinyurl.com is lying to you.

Ah, I misunderstood.

TBF I think they have direct link on preview page simply because they don't want to track the traffic from these pages (instead of trying to disguise), but the practice is still bad.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#99
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

FYI that your site is blocked by this list: https://gitlab.com/The_Quantum_Alpha/the-quantum-ad-list HN post for that list here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25512273

That list is questionable at best. There are many claims the list author makes without any source code at all, though a lot of buzzwords. The reddit r/pihole moderator pulled the post: https://www.reddit.com/r/pihole/comments/kh5dit/the_quantum_... . The thread was more entertaining before the list author deleted every downvoted comment they made.

I agree that it's questionable. I commented the same in the thread I linked: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25513161

However, at least for Pi-Hole users, more is usually better, so I added the list to my Pi-Hole.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? Not the person you asked, but speaking for myself, all the time. I have a javascript toggle I use several times a day, and leave it set to off as much as I can.

Interesting..How many sites work without javascript these days? Does google?

More than you'd think, not as many as I'd hope. Easily 2/3rds of the ones I visit work, FWIW.

Google works fine without javascript. Stunningly fast.

Post reply on HN