Live data from Hacker News

URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

ylukem.com

81–90 of 213 posts

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#82
post #21

Wow! https://preview.tinyurl.com/examplezoom really shows https://zoom.us/j/123456789 link whereas Chrome network inspector confirms the viglink.com redirect. uBlock origin blocks the latter via Dan Pollock’s hosts file and Peter Lowe’s Ad and tracking server list.

Tried in a new profile and didn't see any viglink.com. Edit: the link should be https://tinyurl.com/examplezoom (which does have viglink.com). For some reason you wrote the preview link, https://preview.tinyurl.com/examplezoom , which does not have the tracker.

I think that's their point: preview.tinyurl.com is lying to you.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is a shame that T.LY displays only the footer without JavaScript enabled instead of degrading gracefully. Surely a plain HTML form that POSTs should suffice? I'm not sure how much work it would require for you to support this, but it would help cement your place as a good web actor if you're so inclined!

Can you instead use the meta refresh tag?

Why use meta refresh tag over a http redirect: https://t.ly/home

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#84

This is really interesting. I suppose tiny url gets a kicked back from their ad network for this. I'm the creator of the URL shortener (T.LY) and a Link Unshortener tool. I spend most of my development time fighting bad actors. My goal is to have a legitimate competitor to bitly that people benefit from. We do not set any cookies on redirects but do use cookies for authentication for users. T.LY: https://t.ly/ Link U…

Seems nice. I'm curious, how do you make money / stay in business? I couldn't find any paid options.

Maybe this has changed since your comment, but I see three paid plans on the homepage.

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#85

This is really interesting. I suppose tiny url gets a kicked back from their ad network for this. I'm the creator of the URL shortener (T.LY) and a Link Unshortener tool. I spend most of my development time fighting bad actors. My goal is to have a legitimate competitor to bitly that people benefit from. We do not set any cookies on redirects but do use cookies for authentication for users. T.LY: https://t.ly/ Link U…

Seems nice. I'm curious, how do you make money / stay in business? I couldn't find any paid options.

Thank you! The site and extension are free to use to shorten links. I do offer the ability to upgrade starting at $5 a month which allows custom domains, ability to customize links, expire links based on date or clicks, private stats, ability to shorten links using the API (https://t.ly/docs/).

I also recently release a new feature called OneLinks that are great for social media bios. Here is an example on a OneLink: https://t.ly/TimLeland

Extension Link: https://t.ly/extension

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#87

This is really interesting. I suppose tiny url gets a kicked back from their ad network for this. I'm the creator of the URL shortener (T.LY) and a Link Unshortener tool. I spend most of my development time fighting bad actors. My goal is to have a legitimate competitor to bitly that people benefit from. We do not set any cookies on redirects but do use cookies for authentication for users. T.LY: https://t.ly/ Link U…

It is a shame that T.LY displays only the footer without JavaScript enabled instead of degrading gracefully. Surely a plain HTML form that POSTs should suffice? I'm not sure how much work it would require for you to support this, but it would help cement your place as a good web actor if you're so inclined!

Sorry about that. I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? We do offer a simple to use api that you could build on top of to shorten link. Also an extension that offers the ability to shorten a url in one click.

API Docs: https://t.ly/docs/

Extension: https://t.ly/extension

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is a shame that T.LY displays only the footer without JavaScript enabled instead of degrading gracefully. Surely a plain HTML form that POSTs should suffice? I'm not sure how much work it would require for you to support this, but it would help cement your place as a good web actor if you're so inclined!

Can you instead use the meta refresh tag?

Try curl https://t.ly/c55j

The response is:

https://weatherextension.com/'" />

Re: URL shorteners set ad tracking cookies

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is a shame that T.LY displays only the footer without JavaScript enabled instead of degrading gracefully. Surely a plain HTML form that POSTs should suffice? I'm not sure how much work it would require for you to support this, but it would help cement your place as a good web actor if you're so inclined!

Sorry about that. I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that? We do offer a simple to use api that you could build on top of to shorten link. Also an extension that offers the ability to shorten a url in one click. API Docs: https://t.ly/docs/ Extension: https://t.ly/extension

>I honestly didn't think anyone browsed the web without javascript enabled. How common is that?

Not the person you asked, but speaking for myself, all the time. I have a javascript toggle I use several times a day, and leave it set to off as much as I can.

Post reply on HN