Live data from Hacker News

LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

github.com

21–30 of 141 posts

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#21

I wonder what the purpose of such tools is. Archiving? Safe storage? Offering stock-photos for sale? Or just dropping an uncurated pile images into the interwebs? When publising curated photo-sets myself ( https://notabug.org/mro/Photos2Atom and rather sacrifice features but long-term robustness and installability.

Some people might take photos of themselves on vacations, or their kids and are not satisfied with throwing them all in a folder and using Windows image preview to look at them.

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#23
Incidentally I've been trying out Digikam for the last couple days, mostly because of face recognition. The whole app is pretty slow on lower end hardware, they even recommend having an SSD which my travel laptop which I tested it on doesn't have.

That's when I thought I should look for a web based solution because that would also solve acessing and managing the lib from multiple devices, and now there's this post here. I guess before making another switch I should check out other solutions too and compare their feature matrix and how well those work. With digikam I noticed that it seems to overfit once you tagged a couple hundred faces of the same person, for example, and is less likely to identify that person in new photos.

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#24

I wonder what the purpose of such tools is. Archiving? Safe storage? Offering stock-photos for sale? Or just dropping an uncurated pile images into the interwebs? When publising curated photo-sets myself ( https://notabug.org/mro/Photos2Atom and rather sacrifice features but long-term robustness and installability.

Actually being able to find your photos, especially if you have friends and family who share photos with you and aren't willing to adapt to your organizational scheme. Google Photos really shines when you give up trying to organize your photos and let the AI take over. If I want to find a photo of my wife from 3 months ago -- I just tap on her face and it shows up, whether she took it or I did or her mom did, without needing to get everyone to collaborate on a photo organization scheme.

If I could get that from a self-hosted option, given Google's... track record... I'd definitely be interested, though it doesn't seem this is quite there yet.

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#25

This looks and feels very promising, nice. Is there any documentation on the difference between this fork and the original project? https://github.com/hooram/ownphotos

Appears there have been a bunch of fixes. There are also 217 forks of OwnPhotos. https://github.com/hooram/ownphotos/compare/dev...LibrePhoto... I don't know if the original repo and LibrePhotos will permanently diverge (that appears to be the intention), but I like you am a bit confused at the necessity for a permanent fork and I'd like to know more too before committing to a version.

Wow, I didn't know Github had that feature, thanks for the link!

Maybe the two repo authors can come together and sync the projects since both are so closely related. Nonetheless, I hope there will be more information via a changelog or an outline with differences and intentions.

It's one of the more impressive projects I've seen to replace Google Photos so I hope there's a lot of transparency!

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#27
What's the current recommended way of getting your photos out from Google Photos? And I don't mean manually via Google Takeout (that's a dumpster fire and doesn't work most of the time) but I'd like to automate it for periodic backups. You never know when you Google Account might be killed, taking tens of years of pictures and videos with it :(

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#28
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've used Nextcloud. Auto-upload from your phone is nice, but I haven't found a way to share arbitrary groups of photos except by copying them into a folder and sharing the folder. Also, thumbnail generation is slow and I haven't put in the time to try to speed it up. I haven't used PhotoPrism, but wanted to toss it out there as an alternative.

https://apps.nextcloud.com/apps/previewgenerator This builds the thumbnails in the background. I think it used to get triggered on upload but says it needs a cronjob now. Works OK on a folder of 40GB of photos. What I still find irritating about photos in nextcloud is I keep mine in high resolution but nextcloud won't downscale them to fit the viewing device screen, so I use 20mb a photo with all the UX impairment on…

PhotoPrism (https://photoprism.app/) generates a few different preview image ('thumbnail') sizes to support efficient use in different situations

More info: https://docs.photoprism.org/user-guide/settings/advanced/#im...

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#29

I am looking for a solution like this, can folks with experience comment on their experience with this(LibrePhotos) NextCloud or alternatives. Aspects that I think are important include the community of maintainers in addition to the current state of functionality

For "giant pile of photos I can't be bothered sorting" scenarios (e.g. phone backups), I like Photoprism [0], which is fairly similar to this but seemed more complete last time I tried it out.

Photoprism is also somewhat unique in that it uses Darktable to process RAW photos, so if you use Darktable and have it write XMP sidecars, Photoprism will be able to process the adjustments.

For more curated collections, I prefer Piwigo, as it has a mode where it converts a directory tree into an album tree. It also has pretty good sharing features. Photoprism on the other hand is horrible for pre-curated photos.

[0]: https://photoprism.org/

[1]: https://piwigo.org/

Re: LibrePhotos: A Self-Hosted Google Photos Alternative

#30
post #27

What's the current recommended way of getting your photos out from Google Photos? And I don't mean manually via Google Takeout (that's a dumpster fire and doesn't work most of the time) but I'd like to automate it for periodic backups. You never know when you Google Account might be killed, taking tens of years of pictures and videos with it :(

Why rely on google photos in the first place? If you are taking photos with android devices, you can backup the device folder containing the photos/videos.

Also, I just tried google checkout, and it took about 30 seconds to schedule a google photos only every-2-months-for-a-year recurring takeout of my data. We'll see if it actually works...if it does, it isn't so bad.

Post reply on HN