Live data from Hacker News

There is much less intellectual diversity now than there was 100 years ago

bonald.wordpress.com

41–43 of 43 posts

Re: There is much less intellectual diversity now than there was 100 years ago

#41

> The communists won World War II, and imposed an ideological purge of unprecedented savagery, universality, and thoroughness ... Liberal democratic cosmopolitanism didn’t win any arguments; it won a war, and got to impose itself by force. That feeling when you’re so het up about the Modern World you conflate communism and “liberal democratic cosmopolitanism” as “tHE lEFt”. The true travesty in intellectual diversity…

They're not the same of course but it's common to regard them both as left-wing ideologies. They are both descendants of the ideologies of those who sat to the left in the French National Assembly, as opposed to the conservatives who sat on the right. (Confusingly, the people who call themselves conservatives in the US are really mostly free-market liberals.)

> it's common to regard them both as left-wing ideologies

It definitely is common among people who want to advocate for far right beliefs but run into the slight issue of the most famous of those groups being culturally synonymous with evil. Simply defining the Nazis to the other side of the spectrum is a very convenient solution to that, and probably pretty convincing to most people who are usually not familiar enough with the history and politics of Weimar Germany to point out how utterly ridiculous of a statement that is. (The NSDAP was helped into power by the royalty-aligned conservatives to prevent a left victory, while the left fought the forces that would become the SS in the streets to try to stop them, before they were put into the first concentration camps. Coincidentally, they also sat on the furthest right side of parliament, opposite of the communists.)

Re: There is much less intellectual diversity now than there was 100 years ago

#42
post #2

"Intellectual diversity" of course as always being a code word for acceptance for racism, sexism and antisemitism, etc. in society, cloaked in progressive language. In that sense, yes, the "diversity" has decreased and I hope this continues for many years to come.

Diversity is a code word for replacing white people.

Re: There is much less intellectual diversity now than there was 100 years ago

#43
post #2

"Intellectual diversity" of course as always being a code word for acceptance for racism, sexism and antisemitism, etc. in society, cloaked in progressive language. In that sense, yes, the "diversity" has decreased and I hope this continues for many years to come.

Ah yes "Everyone I disagree is a racist sexist antisemite". Instant argument winner for anyone with a low IQ

We've banned this account. Please don't create accounts to post like this or https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25518129 or https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25523345. We're trying for something other than that here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Post reply on HN