Live data from Hacker News

Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

uplab.pro

21–30 of 173 posts

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#21
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For practical purposes 8 high performance cores will be much more performant that 56 cores with lower performance; in particular if the cores are spread over 14 physical machines.

That depends on the task.

I challenge you to find a single application where a setup of 14 raspberry pi's will beat the new mac mini.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#22
post #13

What could you do with a similar setup? I mean: what's the purpose and/or the advantages compared to a "classical" solution ?

If you need a cheap dedicated (for privacy) server to run a mail server and perhaps a private cloud with Nextcloud, this is ideal.

Nextcloud would be much cheaper to run on a x86 board.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#23

What could you do with a similar setup? I mean: what's the purpose and/or the advantages compared to a "classical" solution ?

Purpose: Learn linux clustering/diskless nodes. Advantages: Cheaper than conventional servers, limited physical form factor suitable for constrained environments such as apartments, luggage, etc. Low power consumption, suitable for mobile/off-grid/renewable. Recommended software: https://clusterlabs.org https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/admin-guide/nfs/nfsro... https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Diskless_nodes Commerc…

You could rent a couple of 1USD/month VPS, or if really on a budget rent a bunch of containers with ipv6 for just a few cents

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#25

What could you do with a similar setup? I mean: what's the purpose and/or the advantages compared to a "classical" solution ?

Purpose: Learn linux clustering/diskless nodes. Advantages: Cheaper than conventional servers, limited physical form factor suitable for constrained environments such as apartments, luggage, etc. Low power consumption, suitable for mobile/off-grid/renewable. Recommended software: https://clusterlabs.org https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/admin-guide/nfs/nfsro... https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Diskless_nodes Commerc…

> Learn linux clustering/diskless nodes.

Honestly, could be as valid with a setup that just involves running a bunch of VMs.

> Low power consumption

Yeah, well, a typical laptop should draw around 50W, which is what, like 0.05$ a day?

> Commercial advantage: Run highly cost and power efficient data centers

Hu, no, in terms of power efficiency per unit of work, you will not beat specialized hardware.

> Infrastructure as code. Full CI/CD with kernel-level control, per node, for any OS. With SDN knowledge, confidently build your own cloud provider.

Sure, also, blockchain, 5G, serverless, microwaves, rust, wasm

Lets come back to earth for a second. There is objectively no purpose for this, except it's fun and nerdy. Do we really have to find excuses?

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#26

What could you do with a similar setup? I mean: what's the purpose and/or the advantages compared to a "classical" solution ?

Purpose: Learn linux clustering/diskless nodes. Advantages: Cheaper than conventional servers, limited physical form factor suitable for constrained environments such as apartments, luggage, etc. Low power consumption, suitable for mobile/off-grid/renewable. Recommended software: https://clusterlabs.org https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/admin-guide/nfs/nfsro... https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Diskless_nodes Commerc…

If you want to learn clustering with physical hardware, and you don't have the power and size constraints, you're better off buying some off-lease business desktops. These i3 and i5 systems with 4 to 8GB of RAM can be had for less than $100 each.

When you're done with the cluster, you can likely sell them for nearly what you paid for them.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#27
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Purpose: Learn linux clustering/diskless nodes. Advantages: Cheaper than conventional servers, limited physical form factor suitable for constrained environments such as apartments, luggage, etc. Low power consumption, suitable for mobile/off-grid/renewable. Recommended software: https://clusterlabs.org https://www.kernel.org/doc/html/latest/admin-guide/nfs/nfsro... https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/Diskless_nodes Commerc…

> Learn linux clustering/diskless nodes. Honestly, could be as valid with a setup that just involves running a bunch of VMs. > Low power consumption Yeah, well, a typical laptop should draw around 50W, which is what, like 0.05$ a day? > Commercial advantage: Run highly cost and power efficient data centers Hu, no, in terms of power efficiency per unit of work, you will not beat specialized hardware. > Infrastructure…

To be clear, the commercial utility refers to the skills, not the hardware.

Re: Raspberry Pi Server Mark III

#28
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That depends on the task.

I challenge you to find a single application where a setup of 14 raspberry pi's will beat the new mac mini.

Maybe. But you have a network bottle neck between the 14 separate computers that you have on a single computer. If you have a computational task you split in 56 pieces and run it across the setup, you can utilies the cores fully. However even in that case I think the Mac Mini will outperform this.

You can use it as a USB-hub though as I suppose you get 2 USB-ports pr. raspberry pi.

Post reply on HN